Resident Evil series plot holes

I would like to dedicate this thread to all the plot holes in RE game series. Do you know some inconsistencies, plot holes or unexplained things you'd like to share?


355
 
I start off this thread by linking/copying this article that I found on www.gamerant.com that has 10 questionable things through the series.


— WHERE DOES THE EXTRA MASS COME FROM?:

Resident Evil is full of mutated humans that have taken on completely alien physical appearances. For example, both William Birkin and Jack Baker mutate into gigantic, monstrous creatures with absolutely no semblance to humanity whatsoever. But where does all this extra mass come from? How does Jack grow all those extra eyeballs? How does Irving fall into the water as a human and come out a horrible creature as big as a yacht?
It makes absolutely no sense, and it has never been explained. Then again, this is a horror series based around grotesque monsters, so it's not as if we're expecting a scientific explanation here. But still...

— WHY DON'T WE TURN INTO ZOMBIES?:

Resident Evil abides by the Golden Rule of zombies - if you're bitten, you turn. Then why do the playable characters never turn into zombies? We are bitten numerous times throughout the games, yet we never turn. Is it possible that these injuries aren't canon to the story, but simply a mere gameplay element? Or maybe it has something to do with the herbs we gobble down like candy?
We get that it would make for a VERY frustrating experience having to restart every time you were bitten, but hey, if Dark Souls can get away with ridiculous difficulty...

— WHY DO THE S.T.A.R.S. MEMBERS NOT RECOGNIZE THE SPENCER MANSION?:

In the first game, no one seems to have any ideas as to where they are. They constantly sprout silly lines like, "Where the hell are we!?" to one another, the implication being that they have no idea what the Spencer Mansion is. However, various notes found throughout Resident 2 and 3 make it pretty clear that the mansion is a well-known part of Raccoon City, so much so that it should probably be common knowledge to all of its citizens.
So why do none of the S.T.A.R.S. members seem to know about it? You'd think they would know about the most important locations of their own city...

— HOW DID LEON GET HIS UNIFORM?:

It's established in Resident Evil 2 that Leon does not yet work for the Raccoon City Police Department. Yet he has a full uniform and functioning sidearm before even making it to the police station.
So, did the RCPD MAIL him his uniform and weapon? That seems...highly unconventional. Capcom obviously noticed this blunder, as the remake has Leon starting in civilian clothes before changing into his uniform at the police station.

— WHAT WAS BEN'S PLAN?:

Ben Bertolucci's plan is somewhat flawed, to say the least. He locks himself in a prison cell to escape the zombies, and while that may work to prevent the zombies from eating him alive, it doesn't account for things like food, water, or a potential evacuation.
You could argue that he leaves the cell to get food and water, but by doing that, he's just putting himself at risk, anyway. Why not take the ultimate risk and attempt to leave the city? We don't see what sitting in a prison cell will accomplish.

— WHY DIDN'T MENDEZ JUST KILL LEON?:

We really don't know what Mendez was thinking here. Right before the boss battle, Mendez grabs Leon by the neck and starts choking him before inexplicably throwing him away and locking the door. You are then prompted with a QTE, and if you fail, Mendez grabs you, chokes you, and snaps your neck.
So, why throw Leon? Why not just do that in the first place? Did he know that he was in a video game and he needed to prevent an escape for the boss fight?

— WHY CAN'T CHRIS PUNCH OPEN LOCKED DOORS?:

Resident Evil 5 is infamous for that whole "Chris punching a massive boulder" thing, and while it's certainly funny, it also results in some pretty big problems. You can't make the argument that it's a separation of story and gameplay, as the boulder directly affects the game's story and characters.
So, canonically, Chris did indeed move a boulder by punching it. So, why couldn't he just punch open all the locked doors he came across? Why spend all that time and energy searching for some stupid key when he could have just blown it off its hinges with one swift punch?

— HOW DID THEY NOT MELT?:

While we're talking about the finale of Resident Evil 5, we may as well ask - how on Earth did they survive falling into an active volcano? Resident Evil 5 isn't alone in this, as "the lava level" is a well-known and popular trope in gaming. But that doesn't give it a free pass!
Chris and Sheva should have been melted into a pile of goo just from standing that close to all that lava. But, not only do they survive, they have the energy to punch boulders and kill a superhuman! We're convinced that Chris is some sort of superhuman himself at this point.

— WHY DOESN'T ETHAN CALL THE POLICE?:

The beginning of Resident Evil 7 starts with Ethan receiving a message from his long missing and presumed dead wife saying that she's alive in Louisiana. Rather than calling the local police, he goes there himself. OK, fine. But then he discovers a video tape depicting a murder IN THE HOUSE, meets the psychotic Bakers, and even watches a police officer get half of his head sheared off. Yet he never calls the police.
There are functioning phones littered throughout the house, and the police officer definitely had a radio. Why Ethan never used these is beyond us.

— HOW DID ZOE SURVIVE?:

Zoe Baker is an outcast, so much so that she literally avoids the other members of the family. First off, how did she manage to evade the family when her trailer was LITERALLY right outside the house? Secondly, what did she eat? Presumably, she wasn't eating the Bakers' food, animals get infected near the house (so no hunting), and Evie calcifies her if she attempts to leave the property, which takes the local grocery store off the table. Did she allow her to make periodic trips to the corner store?


(Source: Game Rant )
 

Bandage131

Finger Lickerin' Good
I thought the only reason Evie calcified Zoe was to reassert her hold and prove that the infection hadn't been completely driven away. Isn't there a file that mentions the Bakers going to town every now and again to buy stuff for the traps?
 
What's with Jack Baker's, I'll just say... wonder potion? Like, how the hell can he cut off another man's leg and it just goes back on when that liquid gets poured on the affected area, yet his hand stays off completely until Zoe reattaches it to his arm?

Weird... :oops:
 
I thought the only reason Evie calcified Zoe was to reassert her hold and prove that the infection hadn't been completely driven away. Isn't there a file that mentions the Bakers going to town every now and again to buy stuff for the traps?
Yeah there's a note that's supposed to be a receipt from a store, I would assume Lucas would go out considering he got the cure from the organization and the whole family is supposed to be missing anyways.
 
About the Ethan not calling the police thing, it’s not just Ethan being a dunce, but also Mia and Zoe. The game seriously wants me to believe that neither of these desperate victims wouldn’t immediately call for help by any means necessary? Especially Zoe whose been trying to escape for 3 years? It’s ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
And the Mold in Re7 has the most plot holes and inconsistencies than any other Bioweapon in an Re game The video he links details the main reasons, but it’s still bad and there are more inconsistencies that I could name. At a later date though.
 
Last edited:

Captain Redfield

The man who killed Albert Wesker
And the Mold in Re7 has the most plot holes and inconsistencies than any other Re game. The video he links details the main reasons, but it’s still bad and there are more inconsistencies that I could name. At a later date though.

Don't you dare to insult the best game in the series. It was well written, a horror game and had the best Chris that looks like RE1 Chris!
 
1. Gameplay.

2. Gameplay and plot armor.

3. Just cause they heard of the mansion doesnt mean they should know the rooms side by side. Besides they never visited the place so it's reasonable that they would get confused.

4. To quote project umbrella:

" In 1998, Kennedy graduated from a police academy. Although he had little practical experience, he was able to make up for it with his youth and abilities. He held a passion to do everything he could to help those in need, but would get annoyed when others didn't follow orders he felt were in their best interest. His personal handgun was a Heckler and Koch VP70M he nicknamed "Matilda" after the movie "Léon: The Professional", and his personal emblem was a skull.

Around the time of his graduation, he was intrigued by the bizarre murders cases in Raccoon City and applied for a position in the R.P.D. (Raccoon Police Department), which had set out to recruit new officers to deal with a growing level of crime in the city. After his successful application, he visited the city police station, where he received the R.P.D.'s newly-issued armored uniform and met several officers to arrange his training, including Kevin Ryman with whom he quickly became friendly with. "

Re2 2019 isnt canon and it's not a remake.

5. He was suffering from shock.

6. Arrogance.

7. Cause they are doors and not boulders. Besides how would he know he would encounter one in the 1st place not to mention he's separated from sheva. As for pushing sections which are also in re6, it's to make sheva / piers useful.

8. Plot armor.

9. Cause he didnt want to. Still stupid though.

10. Plot armor.

Might as well drop this:


" There are virtually no plot holes in this series. Only mistranslations. "
 
Top Bottom