• We've completed one of the biggest updates to our forums in years and have pushed the update live! New forum structure that's all inclusive, prefix system categorizes topics per game title. More thread options such as articles, questions, deep dives, etc. Read more in the pinned thread!

General Everything Wrong With Dartigan / GCN RE Edition

I watched dartigan's recv video which he released recently. It starts off extremely terrible then becomes repetitively boring. It's more of a mocking video about the game's design elements in regards to gameplay rather than its story.

" Re4 deserves a remake cause it would more easier to do so. "

" People asked for a remake of recv cause bla bla bla. "

" Rerev2 is like recv. "

" Darkside chronicles remade recv. "

How are these sins of the game already? I dont get it.

He makes fun of the game's older design mechanics, ( Apparently it's fine for re1, re2, re3, remake but recv has a problem for him for some reason. He really goes overboard. ) makes fun of steve to the point of calling him a " school shooter " , at one point questions claire's decision of contacting leon for him to find chris so that leon can warn him, questions wesker's actions, makes a stupid twitter joke, a terrible redfield bloodline joke, at the end he says that the game's unique plot points; mainly t-veronica inside steve's body, wont be followed up again which is wrong cause darkside chronicles and re6 followed it by bringing back t-veronica.

His sentence is steve and chris apparently having canadian accents which ı didnt understand and again makes fun of protagonists for some reason.

I agree with his sins for wesker and ı also think ashford twins feel underdeveloped compared to claire and chris but ı still didnt like dartigan mocking the game's story, especially redfield siblings and steve.

I dont understand. People talk about the more action focused entries, like re6, about how they arent " survival horror " cause they are streamlined at adventure elements while focusing more on action elements than ever before and yet go ahead and make fun of recv's adventure design elements. And despite that, still go ahead and praise re7 and re engine 2 for returning to the so called " roots " somehow. Do people even know what to say? I remember dartigan praising re7 as return to roots during his sinning video.

It's more of a video about mocking recv's game design rather than its story.

" Recv is designed bad and that's why re4 will get remade cause it's more popular and a much more adored entry! " That's the impression ı got from the video.
I recently saw his video and thought he got lot of wrong with this video.

As for remaking CV, i'm not going to fight battle which deserves it the best but i will say i'd be more interested in CV more than RE4 Remake because its part of the main lore but at the same time due to how Capcom treated RE3R i would be worried if it was another cash grab

My only gripe with Code Veronica's gameplay design was that Capcom weirdly omitted that you can no longer run up the stairs like in RE3 and you are forced to press action button to ascend or descend the stairs. Another problem i had with the game itself was the huge amount of backtracking it had compared to previous games. Sure, the original games had some form of backtracking but CV takes it up to eleven. Still, i think its good RE title overall

I couldn't believe when i heard Dartigan complaining about Chris knowing how to fly jet. He was in USAF, its in the manual of the first game. Ok, i can sort of understand how its weird how Steve can fly a plane. Maybe he learned from his father, i dunno. Its not very clear to be honest.

As for Steve not being brought up again, i think he was maybe referring to Steve not coming back despite what Wesker said about him "resurrecting" someday like he did or he could've just messed with Claire. I like the plot overall in Code Veronica even if it had some flaws.
 

mert20004

Mert_BIO_6
I recently saw his video and thought he got lot of wrong with this video.

As for remaking CV, i'm not going to fight battle which deserves it the best but i will say i'd be more interested in CV more than RE4 Remake because its part of the main lore but at the same time due to how Capcom treated RE3R i would be worried if it was another cash grab

My only gripe with Code Veronica's gameplay design was that Capcom weirdly omitted that you can no longer run up the stairs like in RE3 and you are forced to press action button to ascend or descend the stairs. Another problem i had with the game itself was the huge amount of backtracking it had compared to previous games. Sure, the original games had some form of backtracking but CV takes it up to eleven. Still, i think its good RE title overall

I couldn't believe when i heard Dartigan complaining about Chris knowing how to fly jet. He was in USAF, its in the manual of the first game. Ok, i can sort of understand how its weird how Steve can fly a plane. Maybe he learned from his father, i dunno. Its not very clear to be honest.

As for Steve not being brought up again, i think he was maybe referring to Steve not coming back despite what Wesker said about him "resurrecting" someday like he did or he could've just messed with Claire. I like the plot overall in Code Veronica even if it had some flaws.
Yeah you're right. And definitely chris was in air force so he would definitely know how to fly a harrier. It's a good reference to his past backstory and this is also referenced in re6 where he pilots a v-tol.

I dont mind the backtracking but ı still find claire's antarctic portion and chris' rockfort section boring. But ı still enjoy the game and those sections dont bother me that much. And t-078 can easily be defeated by 3 bow gas rounds and 2 acid rounds.

Steve was brought up again in darkside chronicles and t-veronica appeared in south america in 2002. But probably cause the game is an on-rail shooter and people like to downplay spinoffs all the time; ı guess many would dismiss it. Re6 later on followed it as well but ı dont think many know, remember or care about that either.

I think it has the best story from pre-4 entries but ı still prefer darkside chronicles' recv retelling. I really like darkside chronicles as a whole; it's my favourite spinoff and ı enjoy leon's narration of past events along with operation javier.

I dont need to see a re engine version of it; the game's ps3 port looks pretty impressive and makes it look like a very modern game to me. And more importantly ı really enjoy darkside chronicles. I'm not that interested for re engine 4 either but ı'm still curious about that since ı find re4's story lacking overall.
 

mert20004

Mert_BIO_6
So ı was away from biohaze for some time and ı decided to come back after a long while. I'm gonna share an essay that ı created. It's about dartigan's video on recv.

Also THANK GOD that re6 video is gonna be released at a close date. I couldnt be any more happier...
 

mert20004

Mert_BIO_6
Sin 1: What the hell kind of a sin is that? How is this a story criticism of this game? " Oh no the game is bad it wont get remade! " " Later standalone games recreated it! " " Re4 is perfect masterpiece so that will get remade! " What the hell?!!

Sin 2: What a stupid joke about " steroids " . Besides why does claire need to have a plan? She's a civilian and the game takes place in the same year as re2. Siblings when their relative might be in danger might act questionable. And she was sent to rockfort island to be interrogated but wesker's attack ruined umbrella's chances. Rodrigo didnt want claire to die otherwise he might have done that by himself.

Sin 3: He opened the cell cause he wanted claire to escape. You can bring him hemostat and that will affect chris' story.

Sin 4: What kind of a sin is that? There were already zombies popped out from graveyards in re3, why cant recv have these type of zombies too?

Sin 5: How is your opinion about the game being terrible a sin of this game's story? And this is a special entry, an entry that's a spinoff. It was never meant to be re3. It was going to be re2 but capcom gave it a clever title about a sibling rivalry story. Also what a long convoluted ranting about an older game's mechanics. I played both versions and they work fine. Idk what you're talking about.

Sin 6: Stop mocking steve. He's just a kid with problems. People under 18 can act like that.

Sin 7: This joke sucked.

Sin 8: It's a big island. What kind of a question is that? Darkside chronicles also explains it.

Sin 9: So characters interacting with each other is a sin now?

Sin 10: It's umbrella. They design their facilities like that. Also DID YOU JUST SIN THE OP KNIFE?!!!! ????? Seriously that thing is so badass to use; it's meant to show chris' training on claire.

Sin 11: Even if it was; why would it be surprising? Stop mocking steve.

Sin 12: This is a common complaint ı've seen with this game's story. Claire didnt tell leon to find chris immediately cause she wanted him to protect sherry and take her into safety. She was worried about them and didnt want to get them into trouble. She later on contacted leon to find chris cause she found out info about umbrella monitoring chris and didnt know who else she could trust and contact with.

Sin 13: And this is a sin... How?

Sin 14: Mocking steve again... Leave the poor kid alone.

Sin 15: Mocking an older game's design again...

Sin 16: Repeating a previous sin for no real reason.

Sin 17: I disagree. Bowgun in recv is a good improvement from claire's weapon in re2. You can even fire explosive bolts. Personally ı would have liked to see an infinite ammo unlockable for the game but ı cant really blame the game cause it's a special spinoff and that works the game rather than against it. I dont need a re engine version for it.

Sin 18: You're just mocking a injured researcher for no real reason.

Sin 19: What the hell? Why did you sin this? This was meant to introduce ashford twins.

Sin 20: Cause she doesnt need to? They are simply displayed behind glasses and might not even behave as actual guns.

Sin 21: Mocking an older game's design again and again...

Sin 22: Why would he put the guns back? How else would he be able to defend himself without weapons?

Sin 23: And what else do you want her to do?

Sin 24: Percentage mechanic was introduced in re2 though. Re3 had it too. Besides steve could have just found out extra ammo. You could have criticised the weapons not being unlockables in main story.

Sin 25: Cause he prefers automatic guns? Also what? School shooter? That has to be the worst joke ı've ever heard. Also your sin counter just increased again for some reason.

Sin 27: Cause he wanted to mock his targets? Why are villains being blinded by their arrogance bother you to the point you describe it as a sin?

Sin 28: How is this sin a criticizing of his characterization exactly?

Sin 29: So you agree about claire mocking alfred? If so why sin it? You could have deducted a sin.

Sin 30: He could have done it off-screen when the cutscene was focusing on claire.

Sin 31: Alfred isnt gay at all. Also your mocking about sugimura who tragically passed away is extremely disgusting. Same thing with you also mocking suga for some twisted reason.

Sin 32: How many times are you going to sin an older game's design?

Sin 33: Re engine 3 had this monster though. It combined hunter gamma and grave digger into one, creating a weird chicken hybrid. Besides ı dont want re engine cv either way.

Sin 34: And that's a sin how?

Sin 35: It's just cheesy acting; you have no sense of humor.

Sin 36: He could have found them off-screen. Also a typo there about " lugars " when it's " lugers " .

Sin 37: What? It's self-aware; do you even know what you're talking about?

Sin 38: Mocking steve again...

Sin 39: And? It's just a gameplay mechanic.

Sin 40: How many times are you going to mock the new antagonist for their arrogance? Wouldnt it make more sense if you deducted sins? And stop saying alfred is gay.

Sin 41: Mocking steve again and again...

Sin 42: And that's a sin how? You can control more characters in previous entries.

Sin 43: You have some serious issues.

Sin 44: Your joke sucks.

Sin 45: Mocking an older game's acting for no real reason.

Sin 46: I agree that this was reckless but what else do you want him to do? People under stress can act like that. And mocking steve again...

Sin 47: What else do you want to be explained? And why would he mention his father again?

Sin 48: Cause of umbrella? Why wouldnt they design their facility like that?

Sin 49: I disagree. X scenes of recv devalue the game's story and it especially ruins re5's story even more. Same thing with wesker's report 1 which is also pointless. You could have sinned them without mentioning any positive. Besides if wesker was seen boring as to many, including to kenichi iwao who actually created the series; then he wouldnt have been revived from the dead. I still dislike x scenes though. " Who else are you going to root for? " Claire and chris? Anyone but wesker? I would have preferred alexia to just kill wesker or something.

( After an unnecessary sin reduction and 2 valid sins about wesker's portrayal in x scenes... )

Sin 50: Mocking an older game's design again and again and again...

Sin 51: Repeating sins about gameplay design again and again and again...

Sin 52: So not only you spoil the plot twist but you also mock the animation for some reason. Besides a speculation could be drawn about the music box playing a recording before the plot twist reveal. Did that not cross to your mind?

Sin 53: So it cant be both?

Sin 54: What a stupid joke.

Sin 55: What a pointless sin.

Sin 56: Mocking an older game's design again and again and again and again...

Sin 57: These sins are so repetitive. You dont even criticise the story, you criticise the game's design so that it wont be " remade " as if the game not getting a re engine treatment is a bad thing somehow.

Sin 58: He could have missed on purpose to toy with her.

Sin 59: One of the worst jokes ı've ever heard.

Sin 60: Cause his weapon might have run out of ammo? Along with his arrogance blinding him?

Sin 61: How many times are you going to mock the game's story with pointless sins?

Sin 62: I dont want a re engine version of it.

Sin 63: And this is a sin how?

Sin 64: There could have been other planes, including the ones that would carry t-virus which is the reason antarctic base gets infected.

Sin 65: His father could have trained him? Why is this so surprising? Chris and jill worked in air force and delta force respectively when they were quite young too.

Sin 66: This has to be the worst nitpick ı've ever seen.

Sin 67: Cause he was toying with them? Sending t-078 would decrease their chances of surviving. This is shown in gameplay since the boss fights with the tyrant, especially in plane are quite difficult. While inside the plane; 3 bow gas rounds and 2 acid rounds can defeat it fast before it would be launched.

Sin 68: What is your problem? They were showing signs of relief.

Sin 69: What kind of a sin is this? If she didnt want chris to come and reunite with her; then she wouldnt get herself into trouble on purpose in the 1st place. And ı dont think radio would even work, alfred might jam it up.

Sin 70: It has nails though. It could have followed claire off-screen and just grab onto the plane before opening the cockpit.

Sin 71: How is your opinion about this boss fight a sin of this game's story? If you knew how to fight it right from the start; wouldnt it be anti-climactic? The previous trick works well for it.

Sin 72: She was just mocking alfred. You could have deducted a sin.

Sin 73: Cause he wanted alexia to kill them in case he failed to do so? At least capture them? If he let them leave; that would have gotten alexia into trouble. He needed alexia's protection.

Sin 74: I agree that this scene is unnecessary but to give steve the benefit of doubt; he doesnt even kiss claire. He stops after claire starts to wake up. Idk why people mock that tragic kid over and over.

Sin 75: Yeah? Why is this so surprising? As if you cant blow nikolai's chopper in re3 or something.

Sin 76: Why would they die from a crash? That would be anti-climactic.

Sin 77: You're gross. He wanted to protect claire. And that redfield bloodline meme sucks.

Sin 78: The other planes carrying t-virus spread it all over the base. Due to an accident basically. And why wouldnt alfred want to do that?

Sin 79: Alexia? That was easy. Your mocking about the game's story doesnt make you any better.

Sin 80: This has to be one of the dumbest things ı've ever heard. How the hell can they escape from the back of the plane? They would have froze to death. Remember they are inside. They later find a snowmobile anyway.

Sin 81: I agree that this is also unnecessary but steve's meant to be a kid with mind issues. Stop mocking kids who have problems.

Sin 82: Cause she wants to save him? She didnt want him to die.

Sin 83: She does. You need to examine the hole in order to know the shape. You admit your sin is pointless and yet you still sin it. Pointless.

Sin 84: It does. She takes off the mask after the gas has been completely destroyed.

Sin 85: Why did you sin this awesome scene? You should have removed a sin.

Sin 86: He escaped cause of alfred's scream. He was affected by it.

Sin 87: I can. See sin 65.

Sin 88: I agree that they arent dressed properly for the weather but to give the game's story benefit; ı believe they dont complain cause of steve's love towards claire as well as claire's adoration towards her brother. They dont need to complain unnecessarily due to that, that would take away from the game's story.

Sin 89: Did you forget nosferatu attacking steve? Of course steve would have died from the fall due to that.

Sin 90: I agree that the sniper rifle is clunky but it's still a pretty good boss fight with unique scenes to kill nosferatu. Also you're complaining about an older game's design for some reason.

Sin 91: You didnt understand what he said at all. It was foreshadowing his tragic fate.

Sin 92: Why did you sin this? You should have removed a sin. And misspelling alfred's name as " alfed " for no real reason.

Sin 93: You pretty much answered yourself. She captured them in an attempt to toy with them as her experiments. She wasnt taking revenge on them, she doesnt love alfred nor anyone else. She's extremely selfish and egotistical who's portrayed as sympathetic due to her insane intelligence driving her insane to infinite heights.

Sin 94: What a pointless sin.

Sin 95: Why couldnt she? They were near their base.

Sin 96: It's not completely intact though. It's been heavily damaged. But ı agree that chris' rockfort section is unnecessary. Darkside chronicles solves that issue for me.

Sin 97: How is this a sin? It's a pretty good moment in the story. And you already criticised gulp worm before.

Sin 98: Repeating pointless sins.

Sin 99: Cause of her arrogance blinding her? Wesker could have shown it to the other monitors too.

Sin 100: You could have simply sinned wesker's changed line in x version and ı would have agreed with you.

Sin 101: You... Pretty much answered yourself.

Sin 102: Come on why did you sin this? He wanted chris to come to rockfort and he gets blinded by his arrogance. X version devalues this.

Sin 103: He pretty much explains it to chris. And he didnt say chris is the only ex-stars member who destroyed his plans. But ı agree that wesker's utilization in the stories set after re1 is quite barebones and that devalues him as well as valenfield's relationship.

Sin 104: You're still sinning this scene? Seriously?

Sin 105: You mean only chris? In og version; wesker doesnt attack claire. And alexia's charming voice influenced his mind.

Sin 106: He was in air force before joining stars. One of the worst if not the worst sin ever.

Sin 107: You pretty much answered yourself. And chris could have found antarctic base through checking one of v-tol's manuals or something. The facilities are connected.

Sin 108: Why? They are zombies. They can appear from anywhere.

Sin 109: Alexia didnt kill claire cause she wanted steve to kill her. She was using them as her experiments. And why does she need to know about chris? Your jokes suck.

Sin 110: You have some serious issues. You're just sinning redfield siblings' reunion for no real reason.

Sin 111: What a convoluted sin.

Sin 112: You're still pointlessly mocking this game's well crafted story. This video has no real reason to exist.

Sin 113: Your sinning video is stupid; not sugimura's or suga's writing. You're a disgusting sicko who mocks brilliant minds who did a lot of work for their scripts. Their story scripts didnt deserve the unnecessary criticisms at all.

Sin 114: You're still pointlessly mocking steve for no real reason. You need professional help.

Sin 115: Mocking an older game's design for yet another time that ı lost count how many.

Sin 116: You could have just sinned this and ı would have agreed with you. But it's not even that difficult to do like you're describing.

Sin 117: I dont think you understood alexia's intention at all. She wanted steve to attack and kill claire.

Sin 118: How is your opinion about this game's boss fight a sin of this game's story? I didnt even have much problem with this boss fight at all.

Sin 119: You're a disgusting sicko who mocks a small kid dying. I agree that him expressing his love is unnecessary but it was still a very emotional moment. And that line in rerev2 is a localization mistake. Claire doesnt reference it in og japanese script at all.

Sin 120: If you would have checked the files, you would understand it. And alexia dooming herself to failure is meant to be ironic. Her insane intelligence boost drove her insane and she didnt know what she was doing due to her arrogance blinding her to infinite heights.

Sin 121: Why is that a bad thing though? Kenichi iwao, the actual creator of the series who developed the scenario for re1, worked on that franchise as writer. I fail to see how sugimura playing tribute to him was a bad thing.

Sin 122: Why didnt you sin x version changing the game's story? I would have fully agreed with you!

Sin 123: What a pointless sin.

Sin 124: Chris told claire to go cause steve attacked her without chris being nearby and he wanted her to be in safety due to this. Suga expanded from sugimura's script by making redfield siblings fight steve together before fighting alexia as a coop sequence but sugimura's script still makes sense for what it is. Dismissing x version of course.

Sin 125: I agree about the weapon's mechanic being clunky but to be fair to the game; you only need to hit alexia once and she will get blown up.

Sin 126: Why are you mocking the protagonists? You could have just sinned x version altering sugimura's script due to kato's drunken nonsense.

Sin 127: Yes it does. T-veronica comes back in darkside chronicles 4 years later before re6 gives the screentime it deserves along with g-virus. Suga was expanding from sugimura's script properly. Better than re code plagas spinoff like games that are presented as numbered entries.

Sin 128: You're a disgusting idiot, you're just mocking the game's story due to wesker pissing off claire for an unnecessary reason. You could have just sinned x version's alterations and ı would have agreed with you.

Sin 129: Chris along with jill encounters wesker in prelude to the fall manga which is a prequel to umbrella chronicles' 2003 portion.

Sin 130: What about dead aim? That's the 1st actual game in the series that takes place at a year set after 1998. Re4 isnt even the 1st game that does a year time skip. And umbrella didnt even receive the proper conclusion anyway, the revival plot comes out of nowhere in re4 due to x version altering sugimura's script. I'm sure kato would have been happy by his crappy fanfiction being taken seriously.

This video is as bad as your 1st re video about re6 if NOT WORSE! I managed to pretty much respond all of your sins which is surely saying something. Even at your video about re6; ı still struggled to respond some of them properly. I'm sure the counterpoint video that will be released in the future as a respond to yours will improve from my essay very well.
 
Sin 1: What the hell kind of a sin is that? How is this a story criticism of this game? " Oh no the game is bad it wont get remade! " " Later standalone games recreated it! " " Re4 is perfect masterpiece so that will get remade! " What the hell?!!

Sin 2: What a stupid joke about " steroids " . Besides why does claire need to have a plan? She's a civilian and the game takes place in the same year as re2. Siblings when their relative might be in danger might act questionable. And she was sent to rockfort island to be interrogated but wesker's attack ruined umbrella's chances. Rodrigo didnt want claire to die otherwise he might have done that by himself.

Sin 3: He opened the cell cause he wanted claire to escape. You can bring him hemostat and that will affect chris' story.

Sin 4: What kind of a sin is that? There were already zombies popped out from graveyards in re3, why cant recv have these type of zombies too?

Sin 5: How is your opinion about the game being terrible a sin of this game's story? And this is a special entry, an entry that's a spinoff. It was never meant to be re3. It was going to be re2 but capcom gave it a clever title about a sibling rivalry story. Also what a long convoluted ranting about an older game's mechanics. I played both versions and they work fine. Idk what you're talking about.

Sin 6: Stop mocking steve. He's just a kid with problems. People under 18 can act like that.

Sin 7: This joke sucked.

Sin 8: It's a big island. What kind of a question is that? Darkside chronicles also explains it.

Sin 9: So characters interacting with each other is a sin now?

Sin 10: It's umbrella. They design their facilities like that. Also DID YOU JUST SIN THE OP KNIFE?!!!! ????? Seriously that thing is so badass to use; it's meant to show chris' training on claire.

Sin 11: Even if it was; why would it be surprising? Stop mocking steve.

Sin 12: This is a common complaint ı've seen with this game's story. Claire didnt tell leon to find chris immediately cause she wanted him to protect sherry and take her into safety. She was worried about them and didnt want to get them into trouble. She later on contacted leon to find chris cause she found out info about umbrella monitoring chris and didnt know who else she could trust and contact with.

Sin 13: And this is a sin... How?

Sin 14: Mocking steve again... Leave the poor kid alone.

Sin 15: Mocking an older game's design again...

Sin 16: Repeating a previous sin for no real reason.

Sin 17: I disagree. Bowgun in recv is a good improvement from claire's weapon in re2. You can even fire explosive bolts. Personally ı would have liked to see an infinite ammo unlockable for the game but ı cant really blame the game cause it's a special spinoff and that works the game rather than against it. I dont need a re engine version for it.

Sin 18: You're just mocking a injured researcher for no real reason.

Sin 19: What the hell? Why did you sin this? This was meant to introduce ashford twins.

Sin 20: Cause she doesnt need to? They are simply displayed behind glasses and might not even behave as actual guns.

Sin 21: Mocking an older game's design again and again...

Sin 22: Why would he put the guns back? How else would he be able to defend himself without weapons?

Sin 23: And what else do you want her to do?

Sin 24: Percentage mechanic was introduced in re2 though. Re3 had it too. Besides steve could have just found out extra ammo. You could have criticised the weapons not being unlockables in main story.

Sin 25: Cause he prefers automatic guns? Also what? School shooter? That has to be the worst joke ı've ever heard. Also your sin counter just increased again for some reason.

Sin 27: Cause he wanted to mock his targets? Why are villains being blinded by their arrogance bother you to the point you describe it as a sin?

Sin 28: How is this sin a criticizing of his characterization exactly?

Sin 29: So you agree about claire mocking alfred? If so why sin it? You could have deducted a sin.

Sin 30: He could have done it off-screen when the cutscene was focusing on claire.

Sin 31: Alfred isnt gay at all. Also your mocking about sugimura who tragically passed away is extremely disgusting. Same thing with you also mocking suga for some twisted reason.

Sin 32: How many times are you going to sin an older game's design?

Sin 33: Re engine 3 had this monster though. It combined hunter gamma and grave digger into one, creating a weird chicken hybrid. Besides ı dont want re engine cv either way.

Sin 34: And that's a sin how?

Sin 35: It's just cheesy acting; you have no sense of humor.

Sin 36: He could have found them off-screen. Also a typo there about " lugars " when it's " lugers " .

Sin 37: What? It's self-aware; do you even know what you're talking about?

Sin 38: Mocking steve again...

Sin 39: And? It's just a gameplay mechanic.

Sin 40: How many times are you going to mock the new antagonist for their arrogance? Wouldnt it make more sense if you deducted sins? And stop saying alfred is gay.

Sin 41: Mocking steve again and again...

Sin 42: And that's a sin how? You can control more characters in previous entries.

Sin 43: You have some serious issues.

Sin 44: Your joke sucks.

Sin 45: Mocking an older game's acting for no real reason.

Sin 46: I agree that this was reckless but what else do you want him to do? People under stress can act like that. And mocking steve again...

Sin 47: What else do you want to be explained? And why would he mention his father again?

Sin 48: Cause of umbrella? Why wouldnt they design their facility like that?

Sin 49: I disagree. X scenes of recv devalue the game's story and it especially ruins re5's story even more. Same thing with wesker's report 1 which is also pointless. You could have sinned them without mentioning any positive. Besides if wesker was seen boring as to many, including to kenichi iwao who actually created the series; then he wouldnt have been revived from the dead. I still dislike x scenes though. " Who else are you going to root for? " Claire and chris? Anyone but wesker? I would have preferred alexia to just kill wesker or something.

( After an unnecessary sin reduction and 2 valid sins about wesker's portrayal in x scenes... )

Sin 50: Mocking an older game's design again and again and again...

Sin 51: Repeating sins about gameplay design again and again and again...

Sin 52: So not only you spoil the plot twist but you also mock the animation for some reason. Besides a speculation could be drawn about the music box playing a recording before the plot twist reveal. Did that not cross to your mind?

Sin 53: So it cant be both?

Sin 54: What a stupid joke.

Sin 55: What a pointless sin.

Sin 56: Mocking an older game's design again and again and again and again...

Sin 57: These sins are so repetitive. You dont even criticise the story, you criticise the game's design so that it wont be " remade " as if the game not getting a re engine treatment is a bad thing somehow.

Sin 58: He could have missed on purpose to toy with her.

Sin 59: One of the worst jokes ı've ever heard.

Sin 60: Cause his weapon might have run out of ammo? Along with his arrogance blinding him?

Sin 61: How many times are you going to mock the game's story with pointless sins?

Sin 62: I dont want a re engine version of it.

Sin 63: And this is a sin how?

Sin 64: There could have been other planes, including the ones that would carry t-virus which is the reason antarctic base gets infected.

Sin 65: His father could have trained him? Why is this so surprising? Chris and jill worked in air force and delta force respectively when they were quite young too.

Sin 66: This has to be the worst nitpick ı've ever seen.

Sin 67: Cause he was toying with them? Sending t-078 would decrease their chances of surviving. This is shown in gameplay since the boss fights with the tyrant, especially in plane are quite difficult. While inside the plane; 3 bow gas rounds and 2 acid rounds can defeat it fast before it would be launched.

Sin 68: What is your problem? They were showing signs of relief.

Sin 69: What kind of a sin is this? If she didnt want chris to come and reunite with her; then she wouldnt get herself into trouble on purpose in the 1st place. And ı dont think radio would even work, alfred might jam it up.

Sin 70: It has nails though. It could have followed claire off-screen and just grab onto the plane before opening the cockpit.

Sin 71: How is your opinion about this boss fight a sin of this game's story? If you knew how to fight it right from the start; wouldnt it be anti-climactic? The previous trick works well for it.

Sin 72: She was just mocking alfred. You could have deducted a sin.

Sin 73: Cause he wanted alexia to kill them in case he failed to do so? At least capture them? If he let them leave; that would have gotten alexia into trouble. He needed alexia's protection.

Sin 74: I agree that this scene is unnecessary but to give steve the benefit of doubt; he doesnt even kiss claire. He stops after claire starts to wake up. Idk why people mock that tragic kid over and over.

Sin 75: Yeah? Why is this so surprising? As if you cant blow nikolai's chopper in re3 or something.

Sin 76: Why would they die from a crash? That would be anti-climactic.

Sin 77: You're gross. He wanted to protect claire. And that redfield bloodline meme sucks.

Sin 78: The other planes carrying t-virus spread it all over the base. Due to an accident basically. And why wouldnt alfred want to do that?

Sin 79: Alexia? That was easy. Your mocking about the game's story doesnt make you any better.

Sin 80: This has to be one of the dumbest things ı've ever heard. How the hell can they escape from the back of the plane? They would have froze to death. Remember they are inside. They later find a snowmobile anyway.

Sin 81: I agree that this is also unnecessary but steve's meant to be a kid with mind issues. Stop mocking kids who have problems.

Sin 82: Cause she wants to save him? She didnt want him to die.

Sin 83: She does. You need to examine the hole in order to know the shape. You admit your sin is pointless and yet you still sin it. Pointless.

Sin 84: It does. She takes off the mask after the gas has been completely destroyed.

Sin 85: Why did you sin this awesome scene? You should have removed a sin.

Sin 86: He escaped cause of alfred's scream. He was affected by it.

Sin 87: I can. See sin 65.

Sin 88: I agree that they arent dressed properly for the weather but to give the game's story benefit; ı believe they dont complain cause of steve's love towards claire as well as claire's adoration towards her brother. They dont need to complain unnecessarily due to that, that would take away from the game's story.

Sin 89: Did you forget nosferatu attacking steve? Of course steve would have died from the fall due to that.

Sin 90: I agree that the sniper rifle is clunky but it's still a pretty good boss fight with unique scenes to kill nosferatu. Also you're complaining about an older game's design for some reason.

Sin 91: You didnt understand what he said at all. It was foreshadowing his tragic fate.

Sin 92: Why did you sin this? You should have removed a sin. And misspelling alfred's name as " alfed " for no real reason.

Sin 93: You pretty much answered yourself. She captured them in an attempt to toy with them as her experiments. She wasnt taking revenge on them, she doesnt love alfred nor anyone else. She's extremely selfish and egotistical who's portrayed as sympathetic due to her insane intelligence driving her insane to infinite heights.

Sin 94: What a pointless sin.

Sin 95: Why couldnt she? They were near their base.

Sin 96: It's not completely intact though. It's been heavily damaged. But ı agree that chris' rockfort section is unnecessary. Darkside chronicles solves that issue for me.

Sin 97: How is this a sin? It's a pretty good moment in the story. And you already criticised gulp worm before.

Sin 98: Repeating pointless sins.

Sin 99: Cause of her arrogance blinding her? Wesker could have shown it to the other monitors too.

Sin 100: You could have simply sinned wesker's changed line in x version and ı would have agreed with you.

Sin 101: You... Pretty much answered yourself.

Sin 102: Come on why did you sin this? He wanted chris to come to rockfort and he gets blinded by his arrogance. X version devalues this.

Sin 103: He pretty much explains it to chris. And he didnt say chris is the only ex-stars member who destroyed his plans. But ı agree that wesker's utilization in the stories set after re1 is quite barebones and that devalues him as well as valenfield's relationship.

Sin 104: You're still sinning this scene? Seriously?

Sin 105: You mean only chris? In og version; wesker doesnt attack claire. And alexia's charming voice influenced his mind.

Sin 106: He was in air force before joining stars. One of the worst if not the worst sin ever.

Sin 107: You pretty much answered yourself. And chris could have found antarctic base through checking one of v-tol's manuals or something. The facilities are connected.

Sin 108: Why? They are zombies. They can appear from anywhere.

Sin 109: Alexia didnt kill claire cause she wanted steve to kill her. She was using them as her experiments. And why does she need to know about chris? Your jokes suck.

Sin 110: You have some serious issues. You're just sinning redfield siblings' reunion for no real reason.

Sin 111: What a convoluted sin.

Sin 112: You're still pointlessly mocking this game's well crafted story. This video has no real reason to exist.

Sin 113: Your sinning video is stupid; not sugimura's or suga's writing. You're a disgusting sicko who mocks brilliant minds who did a lot of work for their scripts. Their story scripts didnt deserve the unnecessary criticisms at all.

Sin 114: You're still pointlessly mocking steve for no real reason. You need professional help.

Sin 115: Mocking an older game's design for yet another time that ı lost count how many.

Sin 116: You could have just sinned this and ı would have agreed with you. But it's not even that difficult to do like you're describing.

Sin 117: I dont think you understood alexia's intention at all. She wanted steve to attack and kill claire.

Sin 118: How is your opinion about this game's boss fight a sin of this game's story? I didnt even have much problem with this boss fight at all.

Sin 119: You're a disgusting sicko who mocks a small kid dying. I agree that him expressing his love is unnecessary but it was still a very emotional moment. And that line in rerev2 is a localization mistake. Claire doesnt reference it in og japanese script at all.

Sin 120: If you would have checked the files, you would understand it. And alexia dooming herself to failure is meant to be ironic. Her insane intelligence boost drove her insane and she didnt know what she was doing due to her arrogance blinding her to infinite heights.

Sin 121: Why is that a bad thing though? Kenichi iwao, the actual creator of the series who developed the scenario for re1, worked on that franchise as writer. I fail to see how sugimura playing tribute to him was a bad thing.

Sin 122: Why didnt you sin x version changing the game's story? I would have fully agreed with you!

Sin 123: What a pointless sin.

Sin 124: Chris told claire to go cause steve attacked her without chris being nearby and he wanted her to be in safety due to this. Suga expanded from sugimura's script by making redfield siblings fight steve together before fighting alexia as a coop sequence but sugimura's script still makes sense for what it is. Dismissing x version of course.

Sin 125: I agree about the weapon's mechanic being clunky but to be fair to the game; you only need to hit alexia once and she will get blown up.

Sin 126: Why are you mocking the protagonists? You could have just sinned x version altering sugimura's script due to kato's drunken nonsense.

Sin 127: Yes it does. T-veronica comes back in darkside chronicles 4 years later before re6 gives the screentime it deserves along with g-virus. Suga was expanding from sugimura's script properly. Better than re code plagas spinoff like games that are presented as numbered entries.

Sin 128: You're a disgusting idiot, you're just mocking the game's story due to wesker pissing off claire for an unnecessary reason. You could have just sinned x version's alterations and ı would have agreed with you.

Sin 129: Chris along with jill encounters wesker in prelude to the fall manga which is a prequel to umbrella chronicles' 2003 portion.

Sin 130: What about dead aim? That's the 1st actual game in the series that takes place at a year set after 1998. Re4 isnt even the 1st game that does a year time skip. And umbrella didnt even receive the proper conclusion anyway, the revival plot comes out of nowhere in re4 due to x version altering sugimura's script. I'm sure kato would have been happy by his crappy fanfiction being taken seriously.

This video is as bad as your 1st re video about re6 if NOT WORSE! I managed to pretty much respond all of your sins which is surely saying something. Even at your video about re6; ı still struggled to respond some of them properly. I'm sure the counterpoint video that will be released in the future as a respond to yours will improve from my essay very well.
1. Code Veronica is very underrated RE game, but then again i have lost hope on Capcom remaking CV because they would rush it out like they did with RE3R and only remake RE4 because it was the most popular back in 2000s.

2. Yeah, "Roidfield" became a meme starting in RE5 and its getting old. As for Claire, i'm guessing she found clues about her brother being in Paris Facility only to arrive too late and gets capture

3. Rodrigo was bleeding badly and pretty much lost all the hope since the prison was taken over. I'm guessing he let Claire out to give her chance to escape from death but also basically telling her that its hopeless to get off the island. He does warm up to her and tells her to escape if you bring hemostat like you said

4. It does beg the question how are they coming out of their graves since it was stated that T-Virus doesn't infect dead tissue? It only infects when you are alive and you become "dead" and "reanimate" as a zombie. I'm guessing the zombies you see coming out of the graves in RE3 had recently died and buried, but CV zombies look like they have been buried for several weeks or months.

5. I guess Dartigan is too much stuck in the past which would be no surprise. I personally liked the 3D environments, which was already used in a game called Dino Crisis 1 on PS1(One of my favourite PS1 games)

6. Personally, i don't mind Steve as much as other people. Sure, his voice can be annoying to some, but his character isn't mean-spirited or evil.

7. Agreed. Steve "Canadian" joke has expired long ago

8. Either Dartigan didn't bother to look for research or he has such narrow-minded view on all the prisons. That being said, i'd wager that Steve escaped somehow from his cell

9. I'm guessing he is criticizing Claire and Steve being some "stereotypical archetypes" in movies, but i'm not exactly sure where is he basing their relationship on.

10. No argument there. Plus, the knife in Code Veronica is my favourite knife design. It looks like similar to one in Rambo

11. To my knowledge i thought Steve just stumbled upon the file on Chris Redfield on computer rather than actively searching about Claire

12. Since the game takes place 1998, internet wasn't the most popular thing at the time and Claire couldn't contact Chris directly and Leon has government connections to send info to Chris.

13. His points bugged me too

14. I've seen characters much, much worse than Steve

15. That's actually classic RE tradition.

16. Unless, he can't see forest for the trees, finding right key for the right door should not be difficult.

17. Bow Gun is certainly upgraded since RE2, though the only nitpick would be that it shoots only one arrow at the time instead of 3(RE2) but explosive arrows certainly make up for it

18. To be fair, that seems to be cliche in most horror movies where someone randomly pops out of nowhere. Was this guy crawling on the ground this whole time? Also, it seems his head was grabbed by Bandersnatch and slammed him against the glass but once you get in the room, there is no Bandersnatch.

19. Its weird that film projector would unlock secret door, unless Alfred really wants anyone who stumbles upon to place to appreciate their relationship, but like you said, it introduces Ashford twins and their weird, creepy incestuous looks to each other.

20. I think this is case of Gameplay and Story Segregation. Golden lugers are obviously key items to progress in the game

21. "Why would it deactivate if you put it back" To prevent someone stealing your gun that only you have access to it?

22. I'm guessing Steve didn't know that putting them back will shut it off and was panicking, but i think the actual sin is how the hell Steve get in there without seeing Claire.

23. It's gameplay design

24. I think Steve used up all the ammo on Bandersnatch to save Claire from it

25. School shooter? Nah, more like little bit careless

27. That unfortunately is the common trope of RE villains to be full of themselves and super arrogant.

28. He is more like Norman Bates, but with high pitched voice

29. To be fair, that animation looks kinda hilarious. It's almost like he is practicing his dance moves XD

30. If they wanted to indicate Alfred reloading his sniper rifle, there should have been at least sound of round entering the chamber but there isn't.

31. To be fair, Alfred has very flamboyant voice but yeah, he is no gay.

32. My only complaint about this is the massive amount of backtracking you get to do more than in previous games.

33. Well, the way they handled RE3R,i would not be surprised if they cut the worm boss from the CV remake

34. Because laser sights don't cause heating or any feel from few meters away until like several minutes later, so Claire shouldn't even be feeling she is being targeted. But with everything what's going on, it would make sense Claire to be wary about being watched and being shot at.

35. Ummm...humor is subjective...i guess? But Alfred's lines are definitely typical RE levels of charm.

36. No argument there

37. Judging by the beginning of CV, we see Claire take out guards in slow-mo that looks like very nod to John Woo films so it is quite self-aware

38. Steve looks like he has thing for automatics more

39. No argument there. He almost sounds like Spoony One now

40. No argument there

41. Well, Steve is kinda careless but that's one of his characteristics.

42. Sadly playing as Steve was much more shorter than with Carlos in RE3

43. That was really bad joke on his part. That being said Steve wastes almost entire clip for being angry.

44. To me its weird that the floor suddenly collapses on them without hearing it breaking

45. I think what people really have issue is with Steve's grating voice than the actual bad lines.

46. It's a miracle that Claire was unhurt by Steve's shooting, though his reaction to shooting his zombified father makes sense. I've seen people often disliking this scene because of how it was delivered/executed.

47. To be fair, it would have been neat to see how was Steve and his father's relationship before all the shit went down. But i can understand why he won't bring him again because it would re-open his wounds.

48. Umbrella being Umbrella

49. IIRC, Wesker was originally going to stay dead, but they decided to bring him back. Although i kinda miss Richard Waugh's Wesker, Alexia bitchslapping Wesker around was actually kinda funny until CVX changed it to Wesker fighting back.

50. Once again...Umbrella being Umbrella or in this case, Ashfords

51. Check the part 50.

52. Well, that is all speculation and not actually confirmed nor hinted at. Also the music boxes we see here look like 1800s Music boxes that play instruments, not spoken words or recordings of someone else's conversations

53. I don't know anyone who has window in bedroom to look through corridor or living room, but this is the Ashfords were are talking about

54. I would be terrified hydraulic press bed that would crush me if i were asleep

55. Typical survival horror trope

56. Read previous one

57. Once again...Umbrella err i mean Ashfords being Ashfords

58. Seems to be trend with lot of the baddies in RE. Toying instead of outright killing the protagonist

59. Explains why Ashfords couldn't keep away from each other

60. Although his mistake was to give away his position by yelling while attacking them

61. No argument there

62. At least he wasn't sneaking into the room with Claire's showering

63. Classic RE self-destruction

64. It would be hassle in real life, but it's a video game

65. Well, here is the difference. It was already established in Chris's background that he was in the Air Force since RE1, so he does get pass on that. Steve's father on the other hand was established as researcher for Umbrella that tried to steal information and sell it to the highest bidder. Sure, Steve could've learned to fly plane from his father but it isn't exactly clear about it.

66. Pointless nitpick i agree

67. I took that as him trying to either slow or/and sent Tyrant to kill them. Besides, Alfred had to focus on his own escape as well.

68. I think there was more than just relief on their looks but that's just me

69. Because Chris is going to arrive at Rockfort Island when Claire has already left that place so he ends up there for nothing as it happens in the game. As for the radio, yeah Alfred probably had it jammed since he manages to control the plane to head to Antartica but they didn't know that.

70. They were on the air quite while, unless Tyrant really managed jump that high to catch it

71. Took me less than hour once i figured out the pattern

72. I think he was mocking Claire's line delivery

73. I think Alfred had upper hand there, though.

74. It shouldn't require Claire waking up for Steve to snap and think "Ok, this was stupid". Also, trauma does not excuse for bad behaviour or being uncomfortable.

75. That's because you shoot Nikolai's chopper with rocket launcher

76. Because real life physics say otherwise. Also, if the characters keep surviving everything thrown at them without any repercussions, then how we are supposed to fear for their survival?

77. No argument there. Redfield Bloodline meme can die in fire

78. If Alfred wants to protect Alexia at all costs, what would zombies accomplish exactly? Not to mention, when were introduced to him he complained about his base being attacked and people turning into zombies

79. Maybe Alexia wants perfect candidate to wield that axe. Foreshadowing

80. Well, they don't really complain about cold later on when they are fighting Nosferatu on the roof during cold blizzard

81. He is a kid with hormones

82. That was pretty harsh by Dartigan

83. No argument there. You have to literally examine the size before doing the operation like you said

84. It would take gas for at least few minutes to completely dissipate from the room even if you turned it off from pump.

85. To me it looked like Alfred is just terrible shot.

86. No argument there

87. Again, "could've" or "would've" situation

88. I don't see how.

89. No argument

90. Sniper kill is actually satisfying to pull off....but knife is even more satisfying

91. No argument there

92. It's well made scene, ngl

93. No argument there

94. I agree

95. If i recall, there were multiple monitors there. It's just Dartigan nitpicking the hell out of it

96. I was expecting bigger destruction on Rockfort Island. Only few spots were badly damaged and that's about it. Its mostly Chris learning that Wesker is alive and Claire is somewhere in Antartica

97. I personally prefer Yawn fight over this

98. Sub-machineguns are actually one of the best weapons against Alexia's second form

99. It seemed like Alexia was singing for losing Alfred and based on her lyrics was about them

100. IIRC, Wesker sounded more surprised of Chris's appearance in CV

101. Classic RE tradition

102. Not in the original CV where he sounds quite surprised "Chris! You're here?!"

103. Putting UC aside in which had Red Queen screwing Wesker over for not being able to obtain combat data, Wesker seems specifically fixated on Chris and him in the sequels than any other S.T.A.R.S member

104. Its chilling to see Wesker return, but i always found the rivalry between Chris and Wesker as mighty forced.

105. No argument there. Though its more frequent with Chris

106. I agree. It was in the manual for crying out loud

107. Yup

108. Rotten and decayed zombies that are buried in thick ice should not child's play for them

109. Considering that Alexia has thing with infecting others it would make sense she would want to infect both Claire and Steve, but Chris got there in time.

110. Usually community makes fun of Claire's taste in men

111. No argument there

112. Mind elaborating a bit what makes this story great instead of just saying "It's well-crafted story and this video should not exist)?

113. That doesn't mean people can't be criticised for their work if that's what you are going for. Criticising someone's work is not the same as attacking someone in person as long as its constructive criticism.

114. No argument there

115. Gameplay mechanic

116. This was annoying part ngl

117. Somebody's gonna wield that axe

118. I wouldn't exactly call this a boss fight but chase sequence

119. Steve's death would be saddest moment in the series...if it weren't for the fact Claire's uncanny crying face that always bugged the hell out of me even for first time playing. Granted, it was 2000 game

120. Guess no argument there

121. I love Parasite Eve

122. Guess people really wanted to see Wesker fight back

123. Classic RE Tradition

124. Unfortunately, didn't happen in final product

125. It can be quite hassle though

126. I have no words

127. T-Veronica does come back in some fashion, but not Steve. Its likely that he stays dead

128. Come to think of it, Wesker making Steve into brainwashed ally of his would hurt Claire even more

129. Let alone in Lost in Nightmares before Chris and Sheva

130. Or Revelations which chronologically took place before RE5. Though it was mistake taking Umbrella off-screen.
 

mert20004

Mert_BIO_6
1. Code Veronica is very underrated RE game, but then again i have lost hope on Capcom remaking CV because they would rush it out like they did with RE3R and only remake RE4 because it was the most popular back in 2000s.

2. Yeah, "Roidfield" became a meme starting in RE5 and its getting old. As for Claire, i'm guessing she found clues about her brother being in Paris Facility only to arrive too late and gets capture

3. Rodrigo was bleeding badly and pretty much lost all the hope since the prison was taken over. I'm guessing he let Claire out to give her chance to escape from death but also basically telling her that its hopeless to get off the island. He does warm up to her and tells her to escape if you bring hemostat like you said

4. It does beg the question how are they coming out of their graves since it was stated that T-Virus doesn't infect dead tissue? It only infects when you are alive and you become "dead" and "reanimate" as a zombie. I'm guessing the zombies you see coming out of the graves in RE3 had recently died and buried, but CV zombies look like they have been buried for several weeks or months.

5. I guess Dartigan is too much stuck in the past which would be no surprise. I personally liked the 3D environments, which was already used in a game called Dino Crisis 1 on PS1(One of my favourite PS1 games)

6. Personally, i don't mind Steve as much as other people. Sure, his voice can be annoying to some, but his character isn't mean-spirited or evil.

7. Agreed. Steve "Canadian" joke has expired long ago

8. Either Dartigan didn't bother to look for research or he has such narrow-minded view on all the prisons. That being said, i'd wager that Steve escaped somehow from his cell

9. I'm guessing he is criticizing Claire and Steve being some "stereotypical archetypes" in movies, but i'm not exactly sure where is he basing their relationship on.

10. No argument there. Plus, the knife in Code Veronica is my favourite knife design. It looks like similar to one in Rambo

11. To my knowledge i thought Steve just stumbled upon the file on Chris Redfield on computer rather than actively searching about Claire

12. Since the game takes place 1998, internet wasn't the most popular thing at the time and Claire couldn't contact Chris directly and Leon has government connections to send info to Chris.

13. His points bugged me too

14. I've seen characters much, much worse than Steve

15. That's actually classic RE tradition.

16. Unless, he can't see forest for the trees, finding right key for the right door should not be difficult.

17. Bow Gun is certainly upgraded since RE2, though the only nitpick would be that it shoots only one arrow at the time instead of 3(RE2) but explosive arrows certainly make up for it

18. To be fair, that seems to be cliche in most horror movies where someone randomly pops out of nowhere. Was this guy crawling on the ground this whole time? Also, it seems his head was grabbed by Bandersnatch and slammed him against the glass but once you get in the room, there is no Bandersnatch.

19. Its weird that film projector would unlock secret door, unless Alfred really wants anyone who stumbles upon to place to appreciate their relationship, but like you said, it introduces Ashford twins and their weird, creepy incestuous looks to each other.

20. I think this is case of Gameplay and Story Segregation. Golden lugers are obviously key items to progress in the game

21. "Why would it deactivate if you put it back" To prevent someone stealing your gun that only you have access to it?

22. I'm guessing Steve didn't know that putting them back will shut it off and was panicking, but i think the actual sin is how the hell Steve get in there without seeing Claire.

23. It's gameplay design

24. I think Steve used up all the ammo on Bandersnatch to save Claire from it

25. School shooter? Nah, more like little bit careless

27. That unfortunately is the common trope of RE villains to be full of themselves and super arrogant.

28. He is more like Norman Bates, but with high pitched voice

29. To be fair, that animation looks kinda hilarious. It's almost like he is practicing his dance moves XD

30. If they wanted to indicate Alfred reloading his sniper rifle, there should have been at least sound of round entering the chamber but there isn't.

31. To be fair, Alfred has very flamboyant voice but yeah, he is no gay.

32. My only complaint about this is the massive amount of backtracking you get to do more than in previous games.

33. Well, the way they handled RE3R,i would not be surprised if they cut the worm boss from the CV remake

34. Because laser sights don't cause heating or any feel from few meters away until like several minutes later, so Claire shouldn't even be feeling she is being targeted. But with everything what's going on, it would make sense Claire to be wary about being watched and being shot at.

35. Ummm...humor is subjective...i guess? But Alfred's lines are definitely typical RE levels of charm.

36. No argument there

37. Judging by the beginning of CV, we see Claire take out guards in slow-mo that looks like very nod to John Woo films so it is quite self-aware

38. Steve looks like he has thing for automatics more

39. No argument there. He almost sounds like Spoony One now

40. No argument there

41. Well, Steve is kinda careless but that's one of his characteristics.

42. Sadly playing as Steve was much more shorter than with Carlos in RE3

43. That was really bad joke on his part. That being said Steve wastes almost entire clip for being angry.

44. To me its weird that the floor suddenly collapses on them without hearing it breaking

45. I think what people really have issue is with Steve's grating voice than the actual bad lines.

46. It's a miracle that Claire was unhurt by Steve's shooting, though his reaction to shooting his zombified father makes sense. I've seen people often disliking this scene because of how it was delivered/executed.

47. To be fair, it would have been neat to see how was Steve and his father's relationship before all the shit went down. But i can understand why he won't bring him again because it would re-open his wounds.

48. Umbrella being Umbrella

49. IIRC, Wesker was originally going to stay dead, but they decided to bring him back. Although i kinda miss Richard Waugh's Wesker, Alexia bitchslapping Wesker around was actually kinda funny until CVX changed it to Wesker fighting back.

50. Once again...Umbrella being Umbrella or in this case, Ashfords

51. Check the part 50.

52. Well, that is all speculation and not actually confirmed nor hinted at. Also the music boxes we see here look like 1800s Music boxes that play instruments, not spoken words or recordings of someone else's conversations

53. I don't know anyone who has window in bedroom to look through corridor or living room, but this is the Ashfords were are talking about

54. I would be terrified hydraulic press bed that would crush me if i were asleep

55. Typical survival horror trope

56. Read previous one

57. Once again...Umbrella err i mean Ashfords being Ashfords

58. Seems to be trend with lot of the baddies in RE. Toying instead of outright killing the protagonist

59. Explains why Ashfords couldn't keep away from each other

60. Although his mistake was to give away his position by yelling while attacking them

61. No argument there

62. At least he wasn't sneaking into the room with Claire's showering

63. Classic RE self-destruction

64. It would be hassle in real life, but it's a video game

65. Well, here is the difference. It was already established in Chris's background that he was in the Air Force since RE1, so he does get pass on that. Steve's father on the other hand was established as researcher for Umbrella that tried to steal information and sell it to the highest bidder. Sure, Steve could've learned to fly plane from his father but it isn't exactly clear about it.

66. Pointless nitpick i agree

67. I took that as him trying to either slow or/and sent Tyrant to kill them. Besides, Alfred had to focus on his own escape as well.

68. I think there was more than just relief on their looks but that's just me

69. Because Chris is going to arrive at Rockfort Island when Claire has already left that place so he ends up there for nothing as it happens in the game. As for the radio, yeah Alfred probably had it jammed since he manages to control the plane to head to Antartica but they didn't know that.

70. They were on the air quite while, unless Tyrant really managed jump that high to catch it

71. Took me less than hour once i figured out the pattern

72. I think he was mocking Claire's line delivery

73. I think Alfred had upper hand there, though.

74. It shouldn't require Claire waking up for Steve to snap and think "Ok, this was stupid". Also, trauma does not excuse for bad behaviour or being uncomfortable.

75. That's because you shoot Nikolai's chopper with rocket launcher

76. Because real life physics say otherwise. Also, if the characters keep surviving everything thrown at them without any repercussions, then how we are supposed to fear for their survival?

77. No argument there. Redfield Bloodline meme can die in fire

78. If Alfred wants to protect Alexia at all costs, what would zombies accomplish exactly? Not to mention, when were introduced to him he complained about his base being attacked and people turning into zombies

79. Maybe Alexia wants perfect candidate to wield that axe. Foreshadowing

80. Well, they don't really complain about cold later on when they are fighting Nosferatu on the roof during cold blizzard

81. He is a kid with hormones

82. That was pretty harsh by Dartigan

83. No argument there. You have to literally examine the size before doing the operation like you said

84. It would take gas for at least few minutes to completely dissipate from the room even if you turned it off from pump.

85. To me it looked like Alfred is just terrible shot.

86. No argument there

87. Again, "could've" or "would've" situation

88. I don't see how.

89. No argument

90. Sniper kill is actually satisfying to pull off....but knife is even more satisfying

91. No argument there

92. It's well made scene, ngl

93. No argument there

94. I agree

95. If i recall, there were multiple monitors there. It's just Dartigan nitpicking the hell out of it

96. I was expecting bigger destruction on Rockfort Island. Only few spots were badly damaged and that's about it. Its mostly Chris learning that Wesker is alive and Claire is somewhere in Antartica

97. I personally prefer Yawn fight over this

98. Sub-machineguns are actually one of the best weapons against Alexia's second form

99. It seemed like Alexia was singing for losing Alfred and based on her lyrics was about them

100. IIRC, Wesker sounded more surprised of Chris's appearance in CV

101. Classic RE tradition

102. Not in the original CV where he sounds quite surprised "Chris! You're here?!"

103. Putting UC aside in which had Red Queen screwing Wesker over for not being able to obtain combat data, Wesker seems specifically fixated on Chris and him in the sequels than any other S.T.A.R.S member

104. Its chilling to see Wesker return, but i always found the rivalry between Chris and Wesker as mighty forced.

105. No argument there. Though its more frequent with Chris

106. I agree. It was in the manual for crying out loud

107. Yup

108. Rotten and decayed zombies that are buried in thick ice should not child's play for them

109. Considering that Alexia has thing with infecting others it would make sense she would want to infect both Claire and Steve, but Chris got there in time.

110. Usually community makes fun of Claire's taste in men

111. No argument there

112. Mind elaborating a bit what makes this story great instead of just saying "It's well-crafted story and this video should not exist)?

113. That doesn't mean people can't be criticised for their work if that's what you are going for. Criticising someone's work is not the same as attacking someone in person as long as its constructive criticism.

114. No argument there

115. Gameplay mechanic

116. This was annoying part ngl

117. Somebody's gonna wield that axe

118. I wouldn't exactly call this a boss fight but chase sequence

119. Steve's death would be saddest moment in the series...if it weren't for the fact Claire's uncanny crying face that always bugged the hell out of me even for first time playing. Granted, it was 2000 game

120. Guess no argument there

121. I love Parasite Eve

122. Guess people really wanted to see Wesker fight back

123. Classic RE Tradition

124. Unfortunately, didn't happen in final product

125. It can be quite hassle though

126. I have no words

127. T-Veronica does come back in some fashion, but not Steve. Its likely that he stays dead

128. Come to think of it, Wesker making Steve into brainwashed ally of his would hurt Claire even more

129. Let alone in Lost in Nightmares before Chris and Sheva

130. Or Revelations which chronologically took place before RE5. Though it was mistake taking Umbrella off-screen.
Interesting, thanks a lot for creating your essay as a reply to mine. You make good points. Though ı disagree with some and ı'll share another one that ı created as a reply to yours.

1. I dont think it's underrated at all. It seems to be quite liked by the fanbase to the point a lot of people consider it mainline despite it not carrying a number and ask for a " remake " . It's a spinoff along with this being considered by one of the devs and ı dont find the whole " re(x, insert any word here) " concept that interesting anymore.


" I was relieved to know that Code Veronica was a spin-off, not an official numbered title. "

4. I dont remember t-virus' development well as much as progenitor, g-virus, t-veronica and c-virus but from my understanding; the zombies popping out from the ground in recv seems to be buried alive. But ı dont think the graveyards zombies were well explained neither for re3 nor for recv. If dartigan criticised both games' properly, ı might have agreed but he seems to sin it for the sake of it.

29. That's why he should have deducted a sin, mainly due to alyson court's well delivery.

49. Kenichi iwao planned to bring him back from the dead way before. I would have preferred if the actual creator of the series stayed, he might have helped developers for the future entries' story development. And ı dislike x alterations with a passion.


" Out of curiosity — did you plan for Wesker to survive? "

" Yes, we had plans to use him again down the line, since the T-Virus can revive people from the dead. "

52. You have a point but the series along with the technology presented in it is more advanced than real life's. I still see that possible and if recv was my 1st entry, ı might have speculated that out or something. With re engine 2 and 3; the problem ı have isnt that umbrella's technology is more advanced than real life but that they are more advanced than neo-umbrella's technology in re6. I would rather stick to the simulation theory as a way to tie them up to umbrella corps cause re engine raccoon games being set in 1998 make no sense.

65. True but ı dont think chris' backstory was explained in re1's files either. From what ı remember; it seems to be explained in guidebooks. Same thing with jill. Regardless the point ı tried to make was for re series; young people can perform things which realistically speaking would be way out of place for their age. I still steve flying a plane possible despite him being under 18. Ashley was 20 in re4 but ı find her controlling a bulldozer more out of place even if it makes for an interesting spectacle.

68. It might be for steve who was loving claire but it was one-sided. Claire was concerned about her brother while not having any feelings despite the chemistry between the 2. This is even more obvious in darkside chronicles.

69. True but if they stayed there, they would have got blown up. And alfred manages to control the plane so using a radio would still not work, it might have been even jammed before they escaped using that. I wouldnt mind it if claire reunited with chris on rockfort and one of the files for re6 straight up says that despite it being a mistake. I took that as chris downplaying his past adventures on purpose due to his depression. Same thing with " 3 years " or " I'm the one who killed him ( wesker ) when sheva also fired a rocket. " .

72. And that makes the sin even worse.

76. I dont think real life physics work well for re series. The premise has always been quite fantastical, even more so due to progenitor virus creating all life on earth in the most insane way possible. The premise escalation started with re2 anyway. I'm not saying characters should be portrayed as completely invincible but they should still be able to survive against odds which realistically would be fatal to them. This is shown best in re6 and that's yet another reason why ı absolutely adore the game in pretty much every single way imaginable.

78. You make a good point. No disagreement.

80. True but alexia might have straight up killed them using her pods if they try to escape using running without finding a vehicle. They found a snowmobile after nosferatu fight and that seems to increase their chances of survival.

84. Well he seems to criticise claire not being affected which is explained by the gas completely disappearing rather than sinning the environment. When steve causes the accident; the gas starts to leak anyway. If he criticised that about the characters not dying; then ı guess it would have been fine. Maybe the cold weather might decrease gas' lethality or something.

88. Cause like ı said, that would take away from the game's story. A few lines would have been fine ı guess but if they complained over and over like re engine 2's take on claire and leon where they can shout a random dialogue during gameplay out of nowhere, ı think it would have been annoying.

109. She didnt want to infect claire cause she preferred steve to be infected 1st. She wanted steve to hurt claire but his love towards claire caused steve to break free from alexia's control.

112. Cause in my opinion it's a well crafted sibling rivalry story due to claire and chris' struggles against alfred and alexia. I agree that the game's development is quite flawed but it's a spinoff, being the 1st one in the series, and ı cant blame the game much for that. I find re3's and recv's story premises more focused than re2.

113. You're right but the way dartigan criticised recv's ( and for this 1st re video; re6 ) story still makes him quite insufferable. I just cant stand to overblown negativity, that's all. Describing things simply as " stupid " or " terrible " isnt a proper way to look at things imo. And this video pointlessly repeats sins over and over.

119. For me it is along with piers' and merah's sacrifices in re6 and marhawa desire respectively.

127. And he should cause that would ruin his sacrifice. Same thing with piers.

128. I'm not interested for that. I cant stand jill becoming wesker's slave in re5 at all.

I think this is it. I admit that ı went overboard when ı created my essay against dartigan's video on recv to the point of making insults against his video but ı just cant stand to the way dartigan criticises things at all.
 
Last edited:
As long as we can respect each other's point of view without judging one one another then its all good. We have all our preferences. Thanks for the reply though :)

As for my comment about "CV is underrated" i meant that when it comes to Capcom because they love milking RE4 for some reason but its loved by community
 

mert20004

Mert_BIO_6
The video's release date is finally announced. It's gonna be available for me on tuesday 02:00 at night. After waking up ı'll watch the video. No doubt it's gonna be amazing. I'm very excited!
 
Now for dartigan:

Leon's campaign

Sin 1: You mean crapcom?

Sin 2: What's wrong with leon's haircut? It's awesome and shouldnt be sinned.

Sin 3: Even if the check list was true, the zombie looking over its shoulder, not counting this one, has happened in re1, its remake which doesnt count, re2 and if memory serves, never again.

Sin 4: Leon doesnt want to shoot him, because adam was his friend, it's much easier to kill a bunch of faceless nobodies than it is to kill someone you know personally.

Sin 5: No it is not the same president.

Sin 6: She's suffering from shock.

Sin 7: The cathedral has evidence and her sister, she could explain everything, but it would be better to show proof of everything considering the real culprit is the national security advisor and one of the richest men in america, those people arent brought down by mere accusations.

Sin 8: It's the default ringtone.

Sin 9: They will do more, but to do more they must first know what happened, which is what the report is about.

Sin 10: They get tracked by locating the starting location of the virus, tracking the reports of infection and using that information to calculate the speed of its spreading.

Sin 11: Most of your sins are wrong btw.

Sin 12: Leon isnt that kind of person.

Sin 13: Dartigan doesnt understand characterization.

Sin 14: Why not? It's a small city with a population close to 77000. I can see people who live in small cities like that leaving their keys in sun visors.

Sin 15: Come on this was funny. It's just a running gag of leon's bad luck when it comes to vehicles. It's like sinning dante getting impaled by a sword in most entries.

Sin 16: The engine exploded, the explosion did not reach the front seat of the car.

Sin 17: What a ridiculous sin. He catched helena with a long stare as a sign of showing worriness. Dartigan doesnt understand characterization.

Sin 18: So sinning a video game level for no real reason.

Sin 19: Or she could show him evidence which would make explaining everything much easier.

Sin 20: Are you ok? What the hell kind of a sin is this? You're just making fun of leon for no real reason again. What's wrong with the game showing the flashback between him and benford exactly?

Sin 21: Raccoon city's destruction was never covered up, you're an idiot for thinking that's what adam was talking about, they covered up the government's involvement in the events surrounding the outbreak and the city's destruction.

Sin 22: So? Just cause he wasnt president at that time doesnt mean he cant feel responsible for the past events, especially since he was still a government official previously and made leon a government agent.

Sin 23: If you dont care about keeping up with the story, then you cant blame the game for your inability to understand what is going on.

Sin 24: Another pointless sin.

Sin 25: Why sin this?

Sin 26: Another pointless sin.

Sin 27: The first resident evil game didnt have an asshole in the group, Barry was the closest it got, but he was mostly helpful and only became an enemy because his family was threatened. In resident evil 2 the closest was Ada, but she was mostly helpful too. In resident evil 3 the only asshole was Nikolai, but I'm assuming villains dont count.

Sin 28: Should have removed a sin for his well-deserved death as well as bloodshot's introduction.

Sin 29: They couldnt close the shutters immediately cause the japanese guy was trying to fix the wires on the 2nd floor. Not to mention; that way, some non-infected civilians could have reached them.

Sin 30: Yeah and why shouldnt it?

Sin 31: It's a small town and again the door bar is for extra measure.

Sin 32: I agree that whopper's introduction is stupid but the song is trash and it ruins the sin.

Sin 33: Cause they were getting in and before they started to leave; that's when it started to block the path?

Sin 34: I refer you to sin 10.

Sin 35: It's hard to believe you're that stupid. This company just claimed responsibility for a terrorist attack, they obviously don't care about maintaining a good reputation.

Sin 36: 2 overwhelmingly stupid sins in a row, that impressive. Leon didn't tell her about the cathedral, Helena did, and she said that Leon has a lead on who is responsible for the attack. Now, I know neo umbrella already claimed responsibility for it, but you aren't sinning that plot hole (which is explained, Simmons is actually responsible for this attack, neo umbrella is probably responsible for the virus spreading beyond the campus, which is sort of implied in Ada's campaign, when Carla posing as Simmons tells Ada that an outbreak will occur in tall oaks), you're sinning this because you think Hunnigan, who works for the secret service, shouldn't care about who is responsible for a terrorist attack that killed 70000 people.

Sin 37: It's meant to be a foreshadowing.

Sin 38: One of the reasons why bus lost control is he was driving at high speed and the roads were wet due to rain.

Sin 39: So are you saying that there cant be other vehicles trying to evacuate to a safer place? I dont see how it's impossible for this vehicle to appear and therefore ı dont understand the point of this sin though ı agree that re2 handles it better with the build up. But still it doesnt deserve a sin cause it's a cool reference.

Sin 40: So sinning explosions for no real reason.

Sin 41: How is it dragging though? The game tells you its location and it's not like it can go to a unreachable place that can make it unnecessarily long. What a ridiculous nitpick.

Sin 42: Rescue workers would've made sure the area is safe for civilians.

Sin 43: One more time, it helps to have evidence, especially when you want to accuse one of the most influential people in america of terrorism.

Sin 44: Why did you ignore operation javier, degeneration and damnation? ( Vendetta wasnt released during this period of time. )

Sin 45: Simmons and his men placed many of them in special positions in tall oaks. They didnt infect the whole city with only one bow.

Sin 46: The project ada experiments started WAY before 2013. That recording was done way before during the events of re6.

Sin 47: It shouldn't be a sex tape, because it's a video of Carla being made to look like Ada Wong, it's title is in reference to her being born out of the caccoon.

Sin 47 reduction: no you cant, because no sex is happening in the video.

Sin 48: This tape has been edited by Carla to show to Ada, it was likely formated from a regular video file made by a regular camera, into a costumized tape that can show in a high resolution, because the technology in this game is more advanced than ours.

Sin 49: Or maybe they could have been used to it. And ı dont see why researchers would wander here alone most of the time.

Sin 50: You are a massive asshole, Helena wants to bring her sister to safety before she worries about everything else, Leon is a good guy, so he is fully willing to help as confused and angry as he is.

Sin 51: To quote ada; " But this isnt the time or the place. "

Sin 52: Most likely cause of simmons' ordering the destruction of tall oaks. Besides one also happen during the gameplay period when helena's forced to carry deborah.

Sin 53: Gameplay.

Sin 54 and 55: No offense but you realize the virus is greatly hurting deborah's body right? That's the reason for deborah's weird behaviour during her boss battle. Also ı dont think you're aware of alexia in recv and darkside chronicles.

Sin 56: Another cliche sin.

Sin 57: Why wouldnt helena know leon? He's one of the best agents in us government and played a role in the creation of dso with benford. But anyways; she couldnt tell everything cause she was suffering from shock.

Sin 58: What the hell? Brzak is awesome. The fights are amazing.

Sin 60: Why is this a sin? The files explain this stuff.

Sin 62: And you're more stupid thanks to your ignorance and inconsistent behaviour.

Sin 63: Why not?

Sin 64: And at the same time; it's awesome. Besides re was always cheesy and unrealistic anyways.

Sin 65: He gave the advice to bomb the city, by being the national security advisor.

Sin 66: If you can't tell the differences between the drastically different viruses in these games, you are beyond stupid. T-virus turns people into zombies, there have been various versions of it that make the zombies later evolve into other things, or just turns people into tyrants, but without extra engineering, it just turns people into zombies. The G-virus, mutates people into monsters, that is what Birkin infected himself, Chief irons and Sherry with. Las plagas is a parasite that takes over a human mind and is controlled by someone infected by a dominant parasite, people infected do not lose their intelligence, or at least usually don't, they seemed to have in RE damnation. The C virus causes random mutations, one possible mutation is a creature that spreads a gas that turns people into zombies, but it is not the t- virus, it's a different version of the C-virus.

Sin 68: The last cutscene in leon chapter 3 explains this. Hunnigan pulled the strings and managed to get them to the plane.

Sin 69: Simmons ordered their men to plant a lepotica there. The files explain this stuff.

Sin 70: Come on this section isnt even that hard or annoying. You could have picked out another spot.

Sin 71: How did you immediately assume leon noticed ada while flying the plane? Besides even if he did; why? You're underestimating the characters' abilities.

Sin 72: Why cant they?

Sin 73: DID YOU SERIOUSLY SIN LEON'S AND SHERRY'S REUNION?!!!! The hell?!!!

Sin 74: What's the point of this sin?

Sin 75: What the hell? The dialogue exchanges in this game are brilliant and the character interactions are well done. Should have taken off one sin for that awesome " Welcome to the club. You get used to it. " line.

Sin 76: Not really true, this game delivers a lot of exposition during gameplay too, Ada's campaign even has long important expository dialogue being delivered as you fight for your life in a sinking submarine.

Sin 77: What's the point of this sin?

Sin 78: Piers didnt want to kill carla; it was chris who was blinded by revenge and wanted to kill her since he's the sou captain of the team. If it was up to piers; he would rather try to learn as much info from carla as possible. Also piers is NOT a rookie.

Sin 79: Cause the area is dark.

Sin 80: Why?

Sin 81: Cause while leon saved her life in raccoon along with claire; simmons is still her guardian ( The files explain this stuff. ) and sherry exclusively reports to simmons. Plus he didnt know sherry encountered leon and she never told this info to him. Oh and a special plot info most people dont know is simmons didnt allow leon to visit her unlike claire ( He still helped her but the files dont say simmons allowed leon to visit sherry in the same way claire is allowed. ) and when sherry became an agent in 2009 after wesker's death; he was pulling the strings so that the only members of his family organization knew that she became an agent at 1st ( That's why sherry knew of neo umbrella before leon according to her comments in edonia since simmons shares secret info to her and sherry reports only to simmons who's her guardian. ) and leon most likely heard of her being an agent through claire who learned this info from sherry.

Sin 82: But it is good logic, I want to assume you're not stupid enough to believe the American government has never been involved with killing it's own politicians to maintain it's authority.

Sin 85: Cause sherry and jake werent that close to leon and helena? Simmons wanted leon and helena dead and when sherry got to their line of fire; he ordered his men to stop firing cause he only wanted leon and helena dead. Plus he was frustrated due to all the chaos carla caused in china.

Sin 86: He has 2 handguns in the entire game.

Sin 87:

a. J'avo are intelligent bow.

b. The agents were too busy trying to stop leon and helena.

c. They try to catch to leon, helena and simmons with a helicopter. ( The same one also hurts carla in her aircraft carrier when she was cornered by chris and piers. )

d. Simmons' men deem him obsolete due to him turning into a zoo simulator. The files give a lot of info about this.

Sin 88: So sinning what's shown on the screen now?

Sin 89: Another generic sin.

Sin 90: I dont think you played re0.

Sin 91: To quote project umbrella page:

" Unlike the situation with Raccoon City, Simmons planned to announce the incident in Tall Oaks to the entire world in order to spin a narrative; "the President was killed by bioterrorism and the government conducted a Sterilization Operation out of necessity to protect the nation from an unidentified virus. A powerful terrorist organization plunged the world into danger and the strongest nation, the United States, fought and defeated it." The plan would display the power of the U.S. to China, which had risen rapidly in recent years, and also serve as a warning to government officials related to the President that would attempt to reveal the truth behind the Raccoon incident. "

Sin 92: Come on why did you sin simmons' transformation? That was amazing.

Sin 93: Jeez; why so obsessed with realism?

Sin 94: You're stupid; this is fucking awesome.

Sin 95: You're underestimating simmons' mutation and the c-virus.

On another note of simmons' mutations; his mutation isnt that hard to explain by reading the files and playing the previous re games while studying them but if you want to sin something; why not him keeping his pants and his shoes? I mean deborah is nude but simmons isnt for some reason which feels inconsistent. Though the game is still very coherent to itself and to canon re lore.

Sin 96: You have no idea how powerful the enhance version of the C-virus is (you should considering you get to play as someone infected with it, but it's you are talking about), Piers was only partially in the first stage of the infection, and he was able to wreck the most powerful monster in resident evil (who was also in its weakest form) Simmons has evolved further than Piers was, so naturally he would be even more powerful. The reason Simmons doesn't derail this train is because he is severely injured and has lost his grip.

Sin 97: Guess you forgot that you could deflect things in re4 and re5. Also this scene is awesome just like how re6 is awesome.

Sin 98: So it's not his weakness.

Sin 99: Getting killed by being run over by a train would be ridiculous for someone infected with the most powerful bio weapon yet to exist.

Sin 100: Why did you sin her question for no real reason?

Sin 101: So sinning what's explained in the game now?

Sin 102: Doing the same thing over and over would make things stale. ( Before re4; t-virus was used in many, many games and they decided to swap to plaga for something new. Wished c-virus also appeared in future entries just like plaga did. ) They wanted to keep things fresh starting with re4.

Sin 103: Your jokes arent funny.

Sin 104: So? Just cause ada faked her death in re2 doesnt mean leon shouldnt be surprised like that. You're really underestimating their relationship.

Sin 105: Then I guess you weren't paying attention, because there was a truck trying to run over Leon in RE4.

Sin 106: Why are you still so surprised at characters surviving against impossible odds?

Sin 107: Dartigan doesnt understand suspension of disbelief.

Sin 108: Another ridiculous nitpick.

Sin 109: Why wouldnt it? You're underestimating this situation.

Sin 110: There are several gas filled vehicles on the street.

Sin 111: He was infected and later on turns into a zombie.

Sin 112: I dont think you're aware of recv and its intro. Besides re was always cheesy.

Sin 113: Why are you sinning leon's one liners?

Sin 114: Simmons' mutations can easily be explained; especially by reading the files, playing the previous re games while studying them.

Sin 115: Cause of the damage gas did? I think carla's death might also be the cause of this; more so if you take alex and her tower in rerev2 into account. ( Yes, rerev2 was released after re6 but still not that hard to explain if you delve deep enough. )

Sin 116: Leon is wearing a bulletproof vest, and Simmons is shooting bones, not bullets.

Sin 117: So it doesn't put him down, it only temporarily disabled him.

Sin 118: Ada does have Leon's number, you can tell by how she is able to send him a text.

Sin 119: What's wrong with lightning rods? Besides are you even aware that's caused due to what happened in ada's campaign?

Sin 120: The family obtained simmons' body; it's heavily implied in the files. Plus they selected a new leader after simmons' death. Fos hacked their communications. ( Which means leon and co. are aware of the organization. )

Sin 121: So? It's still possible, and it happened. unlikely is not impossible, and if something is possible in the context of the world this game takes place in, it's not a sin.

Sin 122: I dont think you understood hunnigan. She meant that they managed to defeat all zombies in tatchi. And the gas' effects would wear off after a while. Idk why you immediately assume cure, anti-c isnt needed for that.

Sin 123: They got the evidence and leon says to helena " Our evidence. " . Besides; if helena should get arrested; that means leon should too cause he's the only agent in the field that decided to help her ( The others didnt and saw helena as " Cia's problem child. " . ) and he was also blamed by simmons along with helena. Not to mention; ı dont see the problem of helena returning to her duty, it's not like she could be forced to become someone's mole again since her only family relative is dead ( The files explain stuff. ) and she couldnt be used again.

On another note; the evidence they got would also clear ada's name since she obtained that from carla's aircraft carrier though ada still would want to get a new identity cause most of the world knows her and she likes being as mysterious as possible.
I hate to do this, but...

1. No argument there

2. Not denying its cool haircut, but i'd like to see Leon sporting new haircut once in a while

3. Zombie looking over the shoulderhas been used a lot in RE. Including one of the death scenes in RE6 has zombie looking over the shoulder

4. My personal problem with this scene is how it is executed. Leon's reaction and hesitation makes sense, but the way he tries to talk zombie Adam can easily come off as Leon being "new to zombies" than unable of accepting the reality. It also doesn't help that Adam has like 1 minute flashback explaining their friendship and its hard to get attached to character who were just introduced proper in scene where they are already dead. He is likely the guy who showed up Leon's campaign as one of the people who had hand in Leon joining the government. Sure, it could be argued they grew up close in long years, but that detail shouldn't be overlooked and not have their relationship explained in text form.

5. No argument there. Dartigan should have noticed his mistake

6. Initially, yes, but afterwards? No. Suffering through emotional shock will make your body freeze up or becoming numb when your mind can't process what's going which no longer applies to Helena as she pretty quickly takes on zombies with little issue. My personal theory on why she didn't tell Leon anything was because she couldn't risk wasting her time due to how worried she was about Deborah and wanted to get to the Cathedral soon as possible even being annoyed about civilians getting in the way. Now was it wrong for her to withhold info from Leon? Someway, yes, but its understandable.

7. Considering what they've been through so far, i think it wouldn't hurt to tell Leon anything at that point. Now, Leon likely would've not believed her if she told him from get go, but after going through all the way from campus, sewers, city streets, gun shop and graveyard and even cathedral, i think Leon would be smart enough to not dismiss Helena's story and consider what she is telling about Simmons as high possibility. Also Helena did not know about the experiments done in the lab as she said "None of these were here before" she was mostly concerned about her sister's safety.

8. Can't say much, though i have different ringtone

9. No argument there

10. Considering how long Covid-19 has been around, i find this possible

11. Most of them. Though this game isn't exactly entirely sinless either

12. It is overkill, sure, but i find it quite silly how Leon doesn't suspect this man or his daughter(who looks worse than him) are likely infected considering how he witnessed his best friend turn into one few minutes ago.

13. So you're telling me Leon wouldn't suspect or be cautious about someone being possibly infected? Sure, Leon is very compassionate person, but he's been through enough hardships to acknowledge that once you're turned, you're gone. In Damnation he kept screaming at the soldiers to stay away from old man because he was turned. Sure, you could argue they were enemies, but virus does not dictate whether you are friend or foe.

14. I live in small city, haven't seen anyone done that at my vicinity

15. Leon, learn the drive that damned car, will ya?

16. Engine shouldn't explode in the first place from that crash. It needs to be ignited first once engine is leaking. And in most cases when the engine explodes like that it would turn car into a fireball.

17. I don't think you need to flash a flashlight to people's eyes. That hurts actually.

18. Sewers are quite overused in video games. Can you imagine video game without sewer level?

19. Again, Helena did not know about the experiments. Although, even if she told him they probably would've gone to the Cathedral anyway.

20. Wish we could've had more scenes with Adam than just this one flashback scene of introducing him

21. I agree. Even in Degeneration they said that all the evidence went up with smoke in Raccoon City and the bad guy in that film wanted people to know what truly happened.

22. While he may be not directly responsible for the incident in Raccoon City, he does truly want to end things by coming clean even if Simmons warned him not to

23. To my understanding US was responsible for funding Umbrella, but they cut ties with them immediately once the whole affair went public about Umbrella's experiments and them causing viral outbreak in the city in America. Though in RE6 we learn that Simmons had ties with them in the files and basically nuked the city to cover his involvement with it

24. Often happens in movies

25. Most likely reference to RE2

26. Reminds me more of cabin defense scene from RE4

27. Peter is such a cliche asshole that its hilarious. He is literal sociopath than just douche

28. I found it predictable at best

29. Makes sense. Though, there were no more non-infected civilians at the close vicinity.

30. Because there is no way out of the cathedral other than the secret door that leads through the catacombs?

31. Not sure about that one.

32. Kool-aid is overused meme

33. I do question how fast Whopper got there without no one noticing nor hearing ground shake

34. I think that would be more estimation of the population of 90% being infected than fact. While they can track virus, but not clear number of people of being infected or non-infected.

35. It's true that they don't want to play nice. But Neo-Umbrella is not exactly very creative name

36. I can conclude that Dartigan has terrible attention span. Though Helena did say that there might be something that could clue about the real culprit of the outbreak

37. So, um....Not too subtle foreshadowing. *GCN PTSD flashbacks*

38. Could've driven past zombie instead of running over it

39. I feel truck appearing in RE6 is quite random and out of nowhere. Nice reference though

40. Its quite huge explosion for bus. I'm surprised that he didn't sinned Leon and Helena surviving the fall with minor scratches and bruises, though he would come up with something stupid.

41. One of the problems i still have with this game it is its overly linear design. There are little to no exploration, item management and so on in this game. You are always told where to go and what to do next. I did appreciate the game more during second chance i gave it a go, but some of the issues i had originally still persists. And no, i'm not one of those who say "Resident Evil 6 is not true Resident Evil"

42. Unless, they get overwhelmed by zombies like what happened with the mercs in RE3 Nemesis(Although, Nikolai was also sabotaging the U.B.C.S and causing trouble for Jill and Carlos)

43. I don't think Leon knew Simmons that well aside from what Adam had told him being friends with him over 30 years. That being said referring to my previous point. I think Leon would be smart enough to put pieces together and what Helena tells him could be high possibility after all the dangerous situations they went through to get there.

44. To be fair, Helena doesn't know what Leon's been through aside from his reputation. She does know that he went through Raccoon City, but it isn't clear if she knows him through Operation Javier or through the CGI films.

45. From what i gathered, Simmons sent bunch of Lepoticas throughout the campus and had them self-destruct after spreading gas throughout the campus Though we never see Lepotica's self-destruct in the game

46. Carla was made into Ada-clone in April 30th 2009. Blu-Rays already existed during that time period. Though having VHS player is not that unbelievable because my friend uses her old one still to this day.

47. That pose looks very subjective, though.

48. VHS tapes wouldn't look good on 1080p widescreen. I am aware that technology in RE6 is more advanced than ours, but to say Carla made VHS into HD tape is assumption at best.

49. Most likely gameplay design purposes than plot purposes.

50. At least tell Leon that her sister is in possible danger. I think Leon would've likely wanted to help Helena to save her sister. That would've saved frustrations of Helena stringing him along. Granted, she is racing a clock, but still.

51. Granted, that was before the place started collapsing

52. Missile hits Tall Oaks once Leon and Helena escape from the catacombs to the outside.

53. Would have been neat detail if it was stuck her head and she pulls it out like its nothing.

54 and 55. If she was in pain, she would be screaming in agony and clawing her body in pain and hysterically. Not touching and moaning weirdly. Also her boss fight is quite bizarre compared to other body horror monsters in this game or rest of the series

56. Similar shot used in many movies

57. Once again, i don't think we can excuse Helena on everything based on her "being shocked" which only lasted at the beginning of the campaign.

58. How many mutated sharks/fishes we have in the series now?

60. To be fair, this game is not very good at explaining stuff in-game outside of the files. We get few mentions here and there, but most of them are being told in files. Yes, i am aware that files have been integral part of RE since the beginning, but in those they served to gave you clue about environment, obstacle or even enemy and learn more about the environment you were in as you proceed throughout the next area. In this game, you are forced to quit the game and go to Special Features to read the file you unlock by shooting the Serpent Emblems instead finding and reading them like in classic games. Some of the stuff you don't even find in the game, but you have to go read them in website.

62. Can't say anything

63. Because...sharks don't have vocal chords?

64. Who put dynamite there i wonder?

65. To be fair, National security advisor needs authentic order from the President to do that, though. Though, this was likely due to Simmons being Family leader who truly "ruled" the country.

66. This one makes J'avos, zombies and clones. Though not completely out of place from the rest of the series

68. Not sure how they got through airport security with their guns intact. I guess Leon has some Fake IDs to help him get abroad. And since Simmons declared Leon and Helena as fugitives, i don't think people are that quick to forget the faces of someone who was just declared as dead hour ago.

69. No argument there

70. They certainly made it easier on PS4 and Switch ports.

71. No comment.

72. They look no worse for wear after that except few scratches

73. To play devil's advocate, i don't think he was directly sinning their reunion on itself. But yeah, its awful sin. Why wouldn't Sherry want to make good for the world after what she experienced? But then again, she never had her freedom and due to having bonded with G-virus, she was being tested and turned into agent.

74. For once i would love to see Leon's hair getting messed up and have him react to it

75. That is entirely subjective matter. Just because you like it, doesn't mean everyone else does. For me, its okay

76. To be fair, that was only hidden in Ada's campaign which was initially locked until you play 3 games first. Its been fixed in other ports. In Leon's campaign we are confused but its intentional since its left to Ada's campaign to explain.

77. No comment

78. Chris tried to kill her scene earlier before confrontation, but missed and Piers didn't stop him doing that. He doesn't tell Chris at any point that they need info out of her.

79. Don't think its that dark. You can see light coming out of the window. My theory is that they were too caught up in fighting to not bothering to look who they were and they moved so fast.

80. So she magically summoned a flash grenade?

81. Ok, question. Where is stated that Simmons didn't allow Leon visit her? We know that Claire visited Sherry once in a while and she gave Sherry a warning about Simmons according to the files, while it didn't say anything about Leon visiting her, but it didn't say anything about not allowing him to visit her. Also, Simmons being Sherry's guardian should've been expanded on more imo, because i didn't feel their relationship because it was mostly told, than shown

82. I don't think anyone in right mind would be stupid enough to believe they wouldn't. Although, Simmons's methods were really extreme.

85. They were still in the line of fire. As for the "frustration" part, i dunno.

86. To be fair, i have seen some people miss the second handgun on their first playthrough and some say its not well-explained to you. When i played it first time, i triggered it by accident during beginning

87. No argument on A point. They didn't hear J'avo coming due to all the gunfire. But don't see why they would stop shooting all together if Leon and Helena could be possible hindrance to their plan.

88. More like plot convenience

89. It happens in anime quite alot

90. RE0 has its own issues.

91. Referring to my point 60

92. I personally find quite ridiculous. How are his shoes and pants intact after all that?

93. No comment

94. Is this how you react to people who have different opinion than yours? You love the game, that's great. Its perfectly fine. No need to shove your views down on people's throats. And i'm not defending Dartigan here, his research on the video is extremely poor.

95. Question remains what can and can't C-Virus do exactly

96. I agree

97. No argument there. This scene is kinda cool

98. I think its quite silly how Simmons survives all that shit. I know he has enhanced C-Virus strain, but what are the limitations to it.

99. He is endurable one for sure

100. I guess he is referring "Its not over" cliche

101. No comment

102. Speed zombies has been used in lot of media

103. No comment

104. No comment

105. No argument there

106. Because characters shrugging off things like they are nothing makes the stakes all boring

107. My suspension of disbelief can only go so far

108. I think it would be neat detail to show bandaged up

109. No comment

110. This awfully reminded me of the scene from Independence Day

111. But why was he infected if he was in the helicopter? C-Virus makes zombies by gas, not through bites. Those who inhaled the gas turned almost instantly.

112. I think this outdoes CV in terms of action

113. I guess its matter of taste

114. It explains his transformation, but not much about the mass he produces on his own and can somehow revert back to human. Yes, in the 3rd form he ingests bodies to get bigger.

115. Wait, was C-Virus gas flammable?

116. You see blood splatter from Leon's back when he is hit

117. While explained, it doesn't make it less ridiculous that looks like his final nail in the coffin, only to be revealed alive moments later

118. Though that asks a question. Since when?

119. Yes, its shown. But still quite a convenience that there is lightning storm

120. Would be nice if this detail was shown than told to you via paywall or internet page

121. I'm getting Mortal Kombat memories from this

122. She only said that she "found" the way to defeat virus, but not saying how

123. I'm not expert on US Laws system, but i believe that assisting in President's assassination is gonna be quite severe, she should be at least on suspension for few months and not in prison. Leon could have cleared his name earlier in the story, but chose to stay with Helena.

I want to tell beforehand that this was no meant to attack you or anything. I wanted to give my two cents about the essay explain where i agree and where i disagree

And yes, i think Dartigan is crap and his videos lack proper research. Either he didn't gave a damn or he was just being incompetent.
 
Last edited:
I hate to do this, but...

1. No argument there

2. Not denying its cool haircut, but i'd like to see Leon sporting new haircut once in a while

3. Zombie looking over the shoulderhas been used a lot in RE. Including one of the death scenes in RE6 has zombie looking over the shoulder

4. My personal problem with this scene is how it is executed. Leon's reaction and hesitation makes sense, but the way he tries to talk zombie Adam can easily come off as Leon being "new to zombies" than unable of accepting the reality. It also doesn't help that Adam has like 1 minute flashback explaining their friendship and its hard to get attached to character who were just introduced proper in scene where they are already dead. He is likely the guy who showed up Leon's campaign as one of the people who had hand in Leon joining the government. Sure, it could be argued they grew up close in long years, but that detail shouldn't be overlooked and not have their relationship explained in text form.

5. No argument there. Dartigan should have noticed his mistake

6. Initially, yes, but afterwards? No. Suffering through emotional shock will make your body freeze up or becoming numb when your mind can't process what's going which no longer applies to Helena as she pretty quickly takes on zombies with little issue. My personal theory on why she didn't tell Leon anything was because she couldn't risk wasting her time due to how worried she was about Deborah and wanted to get to the Cathedral soon as possible even being annoyed about civilians getting in the way. Now was it wrong for her to withhold info from Leon? Someway, yes, but its understandable.

7. Considering what they've been through so far, i think it wouldn't hurt to tell Leon anything at that point. Now, Leon likely would've not believed her if she told him from get go, but after going through all the way from campus, sewers, city streets, gun shop and graveyard and even cathedral, i think Leon would be smart enough to not dismiss Helena's story and consider what she is telling about Simmons as high possibility. Also Helena did not know about the experiments done in the lab as she said "None of these were here before" she was mostly concerned about her sister's safety.

8. Can't say much, though i have different ringtone

9. No argument there

10. Considering how long Covid-19 has been around, i find this possible

11. Most of them. Though this game isn't exactly entirely sinless either

12. It is overkill, sure, but i find it quite silly how Leon doesn't suspect this man or his daughter(who looks worse than him) are likely infected considering how he witnessed his best friend turn into one few minutes ago.

13. So you're telling me Leon wouldn't suspect or be cautious about someone being possibly infected? Sure, Leon is very compassionate person, but he's been through enough hardships to acknowledge that once you're turned, you're gone. In Damnation he kept screaming at the soldiers to stay away from old man because he was turned. Sure, you could argue they were enemies, but virus does not dictate whether you are friend or foe.

14. I live in small city, haven't seen anyone done that at my vicinity

15. Leon, learn the drive that damned car, will ya?

16. Engine shouldn't explode in the first place from that crash. It needs to be ignited first once engine is leaking. And in most cases when the engine explodes like that it would turn car into a fireball.

17. I don't think you need to flash a flashlight to people's eyes. That hurts actually.

18. Sewers are quite overused in video games. Can you imagine video game without sewer level?

19. Again, Helena did not know about the experiments. Although, even if she told him they probably would've gone to the Cathedral anyway.

20. Wish we could've had more scenes with Adam than just this one flashback scene of introducing him

21. I agree. Even in Degeneration they said that all the evidence went up with smoke in Raccoon City and the bad guy in that film wanted people to know what truly happened.

22. While he may be not directly responsible for the incident in Raccoon City, he does truly want to end things by coming clean even if Simmons warned him not to

23. To my understanding US was responsible for funding Umbrella, but they cut ties with them immediately once the whole affair went public about Umbrella's experiments and them causing viral outbreak in the city in America. Though in RE6 we learn that Simmons had ties with them in the files and basically nuked the city to cover his involvement with it

24. Often happens in movies

25. Most likely reference to RE2

26. Reminds me more of cabin defense scene from RE4

27. Peter is such a cliche asshole that its hilarious. He is literal sociopath than just douche

28. I found it predictable at best

29. Makes sense. Though, there were no more non-infected civilians at the close vicinity.

30. Because there is no way out of the cathedral other than the secret door that leads through the catacombs?

31. Not sure about that one.

32. Kool-aid is overused meme

33. I do question how fast Whopper got there without no one noticing nor hearing ground shake

34. I think that would be more estimation of the population of 90% being infected than fact. While they can track virus, but not clear number of people of being infected or non-infected.

35. It's true that they don't want to play nice. But Neo-Umbrella is not exactly very creative name

36. I can conclude that Dartigan has terrible attention span. Though Helena did say that there might be something that could clue about the real culprit of the outbreak

37. So, um....Not too subtle foreshadowing. *GCN PTSD flashbacks*

38. Could've driven past zombie instead of running over it

39. I feel truck appearing in RE6 is quite random and out of nowhere. Nice reference though

40. Its quite huge explosion for bus. I'm surprised that he didn't sinned Leon and Helena surviving the fall with minor scratches and bruises, though he would come up with something stupid.

41. One of the problems i still have with this game it is its overly linear design. There are little to no exploration, item management and so on in this game. You are always told where to go and what to do next. I did appreciate the game more during second chance i gave it a go, but some of the issues i had originally still persists. And no, i'm not one of those who say "Resident Evil 6 is not true Resident Evil"

42. Unless, they get overwhelmed by zombies like what happened with the mercs in RE3 Nemesis(Although, Nikolai was also sabotaging the U.B.C.S and causing trouble for Jill and Carlos)

43. I don't think Leon knew Simmons that well aside from what Adam had told him being friends with him over 30 years. That being said referring to my previous point. I think Leon would be smart enough to put pieces together and what Helena tells him could be high possibility after all the dangerous situations they went through to get there.

44. To be fair, Helena doesn't know what Leon's been through aside from his reputation. She does know that he went through Raccoon City, but it isn't clear if she knows him through Operation Javier or through the CGI films.

45. From what i gathered, Simmons sent bunch of Lepoticas throughout the campus and had them self-destruct after spreading gas throughout the campus Though we never see Lepotica's self-destruct in the game

46. Carla was made into Ada-clone in April 30th 2009. Blu-Rays already existed during that time period. Though having VHS player is not that unbelievable because my friend uses her old one still to this day.

47. That pose looks very subjective, though.

48. VHS tapes wouldn't look good on 1080p widescreen. I am aware that technology in RE6 is more advanced than ours, but to say Carla made VHS into HD tape is assumption at best.

49. Most likely gameplay design purposes than plot purposes.

50. At least tell Leon that her sister is in possible danger. I think Leon would've likely wanted to help Helena to save her sister. That would've saved frustrations of Helena stringing him along. Granted, she is racing a clock, but still.

51. Granted, that was before the place started collapsing

52. Missile hits Tall Oaks once Leon and Helena escape from the catacombs to the outside.

53. Would have been neat detail if it was stuck her head and she pulls it out like its nothing.

54 and 55. If she was in pain, she would be screaming in agony and clawing her body in pain and hysterically. Not touching and moaning weirdly. Also her boss fight is quite bizarre compared to other body horror monsters in this game or rest of the series

56. Similar shot used in many movies

57. Once again, i don't think we can excuse Helena on everything based on her "being shocked" which only lasted at the beginning of the campaign.

58. How many mutated sharks/fishes we have in the series now?

60. To be fair, this game is not very good at explaining stuff in-game outside of the files. We get few mentions here and there, but most of them are being told in files. Yes, i am aware that files have been integral part of RE since the beginning, but in those they served to gave you clue about environment, obstacle or even enemy and learn more about the environment you were in as you proceed throughout the next area. In this game, you are forced to quit the game and go to Special Features to read the file you unlock by shooting the Serpent Emblems instead finding and reading them like in classic games. Some of the stuff you don't even find in the game, but you have to go read them in website.

62. Can't say anything

63. Because...sharks don't have vocal chords?

64. Who put dynamite there i wonder?

65. To be fair, National security advisor needs authentic order from the President to do that, though. Though, this was likely due to Simmons being Family leader who truly "ruled" the country.

66. This one makes J'avos, zombies and clones. Though not completely out of place from the rest of the series

68. Not sure how they got through airport security with their guns intact. I guess Leon has some Fake IDs to help him get abroad. And since Simmons declared Leon and Helena as fugitives, i don't think people are that quick to forget the faces of someone who was just declared as dead hour ago.

69. No argument there

70. They certainly made it easier on PS4 and Switch ports.

71. No comment.

72. They look no worse for wear after that except few scratches

73. To play devil's advocate, i don't think he was directly sinning their reunion on itself. But yeah, its awful sin. Why wouldn't Sherry want to make good for the world after what she experienced? But then again, she never had her freedom and due to having bonded with G-virus, she was being tested and turned into agent.

74. For once i would love to see Leon's hair getting messed up and have him react to it

75. That is entirely subjective matter. Just because you like it, doesn't mean everyone else does. For me, its okay

76. To be fair, that was only hidden in Ada's campaign which was initially locked until you play 3 games first. Its been fixed in other ports. In Leon's campaign we are confused but its intentional since its left to Ada's campaign to explain.

77. No comment

78. Chris tried to kill her scene earlier before confrontation, but missed and Piers didn't stop him doing that. He doesn't tell Chris at any point that they need info out of her.

79. Don't think its that dark. You can see light coming out of the window. My theory is that they were too caught up in fighting to not bothering to look who they were and they moved so fast.

80. So she magically summoned a flash grenade?

81. Ok, question. Where is stated that Simmons didn't allow Leon visit her? We know that Claire visited Sherry once in a while and she gave Sherry a warning about Simmons according to the files, while it didn't say anything about Leon visiting her, but it didn't say anything about not allowing him to visit her. Also, Simmons being Sherry's guardian should've been expanded on more imo, because i didn't feel their relationship because it was mostly told, than shown

82. I don't think anyone in right mind would be stupid enough to believe they wouldn't. Although, Simmons's methods were really extreme.

85. They were still in the line of fire. As for the "frustration" part, i dunno.

86. To be fair, i have seen some people miss the second handgun on their first playthrough and some say its not well-explained to you. When i played it first time, i triggered it by accident during beginning

87. No argument on A point. They didn't hear J'avo coming due to all the gunfire. But don't see why they would stop shooting all together if Leon and Helena could be possible hindrance to their plan.

88. More like plot convenience

89. It happens in anime quite alot

90. RE0 has its own issues.

91. Referring to my point 60

92. I personally find quite ridiculous. How are his shoes and pants intact after all that?

93. No comment

94. Is this how you react to people who have different opinion than yours? You love the game, that's great. Its perfectly fine. No need to shove your views down on people's throats. And i'm not defending Dartigan here, his research on the video is extremely poor.

95. Question remains what can and can't C-Virus do exactly

96. I agree

97. No argument there. This scene is kinda cool

98. I think its quite silly how Simmons survives all that shit. I know he has enhanced C-Virus strain, but what are the limitations to it.

99. He is endurable one for sure

100. I guess he is referring "Its not over" cliche

101. No comment

102. Speed zombies has been used in lot of media

103. No comment

104. No comment

105. No argument there

106. Because characters shrugging off things like they are nothing makes the stakes all boring

107. My suspension of disbelief can only go so far

108. I think it would be neat detail to show bandaged up

109. No comment

110. This awfully reminded me of the scene from Independence Day

111. But why was he infected if he was in the helicopter? C-Virus makes zombies by gas, not through bites. Those who inhaled the gas turned almost instantly.

112. I think this outdoes CV in terms of action

113. I guess its matter of taste

114. It explains his transformation, but not much about the mass he produces on his own and can somehow revert back to human. Yes, in the 3rd form he ingests bodies to get bigger.

115. Wait, was C-Virus gas flammable?

116. You see blood splatter from Leon's back when he is hit

117. While explained, it doesn't make it less ridiculous that looks like his final nail in the coffin, only to be revealed alive moments later

118. Though that asks a question. Since when?

119. Yes, its shown. But still quite a convenience that there is lightning storm

120. Would be nice if this detail was shown than told to you via paywall or internet page

121. I'm getting Mortal Kombat memories from this

122. She only said that she "found" the way to defeat virus, but not saying how

123. I'm not expert on US Laws system, but i believe that assisting in President's assassination is gonna be quite severe, she should be at least on suspension for few months and not in prison. Leon could have cleared his name earlier in the story, but chose to stay with Helena.

I want to tell beforehand that this was no meant to attack you or anything. I wanted to give my two cents about the essay explain where i agree and where i disagree

And yes, i think Dartigan is crap and his videos lack proper research. Either he didn't gave a damn or he was just being incompetent.
This is really good!

My video essay response draws from the original essay responses that started this post, however, some of your responses I actually bring up in some of my responses like how I also think it's stupid how the files are unlocked in RE6 and made worse by having critical details missing in-game to have them available online. It backs up the criticism that a story is lazily told or written which is hard to defend when you have conflicts like that. I'm a firm believer that any game should have its story told in full within the game. To my knowledge, Resident Evil 5 didn't require the BSAA emblems to unlock certain Library files and that game had a smaller story in scale compared to 6. More confusion to me why Capcom decided to go that route. Dartigan doesn't get a free pass nevertheless, but yeah, no story details should go missing.

In any case, good responses!
 

mert20004

Mert_BIO_6
I hate to do this, but...

1. No argument there

2. Not denying its cool haircut, but i'd like to see Leon sporting new haircut once in a while

3. Zombie looking over the shoulderhas been used a lot in RE. Including one of the death scenes in RE6 has zombie looking over the shoulder

4. My personal problem with this scene is how it is executed. Leon's reaction and hesitation makes sense, but the way he tries to talk zombie Adam can easily come off as Leon being "new to zombies" than unable of accepting the reality. It also doesn't help that Adam has like 1 minute flashback explaining their friendship and its hard to get attached to character who were just introduced proper in scene where they are already dead. He is likely the guy who showed up Leon's campaign as one of the people who had hand in Leon joining the government. Sure, it could be argued they grew up close in long years, but that detail shouldn't be overlooked and not have their relationship explained in text form.

5. No argument there. Dartigan should have noticed his mistake

6. Initially, yes, but afterwards? No. Suffering through emotional shock will make your body freeze up or becoming numb when your mind can't process what's going which no longer applies to Helena as she pretty quickly takes on zombies with little issue. My personal theory on why she didn't tell Leon anything was because she couldn't risk wasting her time due to how worried she was about Deborah and wanted to get to the Cathedral soon as possible even being annoyed about civilians getting in the way. Now was it wrong for her to withhold info from Leon? Someway, yes, but its understandable.

7. Considering what they've been through so far, i think it wouldn't hurt to tell Leon anything at that point. Now, Leon likely would've not believed her if she told him from get go, but after going through all the way from campus, sewers, city streets, gun shop and graveyard and even cathedral, i think Leon would be smart enough to not dismiss Helena's story and consider what she is telling about Simmons as high possibility. Also Helena did not know about the experiments done in the lab as she said "None of these were here before" she was mostly concerned about her sister's safety.

8. Can't say much, though i have different ringtone

9. No argument there

10. Considering how long Covid-19 has been around, i find this possible

11. Most of them. Though this game isn't exactly entirely sinless either

12. It is overkill, sure, but i find it quite silly how Leon doesn't suspect this man or his daughter(who looks worse than him) are likely infected considering how he witnessed his best friend turn into one few minutes ago.

13. So you're telling me Leon wouldn't suspect or be cautious about someone being possibly infected? Sure, Leon is very compassionate person, but he's been through enough hardships to acknowledge that once you're turned, you're gone. In Damnation he kept screaming at the soldiers to stay away from old man because he was turned. Sure, you could argue they were enemies, but virus does not dictate whether you are friend or foe.

14. I live in small city, haven't seen anyone done that at my vicinity

15. Leon, learn the drive that damned car, will ya?

16. Engine shouldn't explode in the first place from that crash. It needs to be ignited first once engine is leaking. And in most cases when the engine explodes like that it would turn car into a fireball.

17. I don't think you need to flash a flashlight to people's eyes. That hurts actually.

18. Sewers are quite overused in video games. Can you imagine video game without sewer level?

19. Again, Helena did not know about the experiments. Although, even if she told him they probably would've gone to the Cathedral anyway.

20. Wish we could've had more scenes with Adam than just this one flashback scene of introducing him

21. I agree. Even in Degeneration they said that all the evidence went up with smoke in Raccoon City and the bad guy in that film wanted people to know what truly happened.

22. While he may be not directly responsible for the incident in Raccoon City, he does truly want to end things by coming clean even if Simmons warned him not to

23. To my understanding US was responsible for funding Umbrella, but they cut ties with them immediately once the whole affair went public about Umbrella's experiments and them causing viral outbreak in the city in America. Though in RE6 we learn that Simmons had ties with them in the files and basically nuked the city to cover his involvement with it

24. Often happens in movies

25. Most likely reference to RE2

26. Reminds me more of cabin defense scene from RE4

27. Peter is such a cliche asshole that its hilarious. He is literal sociopath than just douche

28. I found it predictable at best

29. Makes sense. Though, there were no more non-infected civilians at the close vicinity.

30. Because there is no way out of the cathedral other than the secret door that leads through the catacombs?

31. Not sure about that one.

32. Kool-aid is overused meme

33. I do question how fast Whopper got there without no one noticing nor hearing ground shake

34. I think that would be more estimation of the population of 90% being infected than fact. While they can track virus, but not clear number of people of being infected or non-infected.

35. It's true that they don't want to play nice. But Neo-Umbrella is not exactly very creative name

36. I can conclude that Dartigan has terrible attention span. Though Helena did say that there might be something that could clue about the real culprit of the outbreak

37. So, um....Not too subtle foreshadowing. *GCN PTSD flashbacks*

38. Could've driven past zombie instead of running over it

39. I feel truck appearing in RE6 is quite random and out of nowhere. Nice reference though

40. Its quite huge explosion for bus. I'm surprised that he didn't sinned Leon and Helena surviving the fall with minor scratches and bruises, though he would come up with something stupid.

41. One of the problems i still have with this game it is its overly linear design. There are little to no exploration, item management and so on in this game. You are always told where to go and what to do next. I did appreciate the game more during second chance i gave it a go, but some of the issues i had originally still persists. And no, i'm not one of those who say "Resident Evil 6 is not true Resident Evil"

42. Unless, they get overwhelmed by zombies like what happened with the mercs in RE3 Nemesis(Although, Nikolai was also sabotaging the U.B.C.S and causing trouble for Jill and Carlos)

43. I don't think Leon knew Simmons that well aside from what Adam had told him being friends with him over 30 years. That being said referring to my previous point. I think Leon would be smart enough to put pieces together and what Helena tells him could be high possibility after all the dangerous situations they went through to get there.

44. To be fair, Helena doesn't know what Leon's been through aside from his reputation. She does know that he went through Raccoon City, but it isn't clear if she knows him through Operation Javier or through the CGI films.

45. From what i gathered, Simmons sent bunch of Lepoticas throughout the campus and had them self-destruct after spreading gas throughout the campus Though we never see Lepotica's self-destruct in the game

46. Carla was made into Ada-clone in April 30th 2009. Blu-Rays already existed during that time period. Though having VHS player is not that unbelievable because my friend uses her old one still to this day.

47. That pose looks very subjective, though.

48. VHS tapes wouldn't look good on 1080p widescreen. I am aware that technology in RE6 is more advanced than ours, but to say Carla made VHS into HD tape is assumption at best.

49. Most likely gameplay design purposes than plot purposes.

50. At least tell Leon that her sister is in possible danger. I think Leon would've likely wanted to help Helena to save her sister. That would've saved frustrations of Helena stringing him along. Granted, she is racing a clock, but still.

51. Granted, that was before the place started collapsing

52. Missile hits Tall Oaks once Leon and Helena escape from the catacombs to the outside.

53. Would have been neat detail if it was stuck her head and she pulls it out like its nothing.

54 and 55. If she was in pain, she would be screaming in agony and clawing her body in pain and hysterically. Not touching and moaning weirdly. Also her boss fight is quite bizarre compared to other body horror monsters in this game or rest of the series

56. Similar shot used in many movies

57. Once again, i don't think we can excuse Helena on everything based on her "being shocked" which only lasted at the beginning of the campaign.

58. How many mutated sharks/fishes we have in the series now?

60. To be fair, this game is not very good at explaining stuff in-game outside of the files. We get few mentions here and there, but most of them are being told in files. Yes, i am aware that files have been integral part of RE since the beginning, but in those they served to gave you clue about environment, obstacle or even enemy and learn more about the environment you were in as you proceed throughout the next area. In this game, you are forced to quit the game and go to Special Features to read the file you unlock by shooting the Serpent Emblems instead finding and reading them like in classic games. Some of the stuff you don't even find in the game, but you have to go read them in website.

62. Can't say anything

63. Because...sharks don't have vocal chords?

64. Who put dynamite there i wonder?

65. To be fair, National security advisor needs authentic order from the President to do that, though. Though, this was likely due to Simmons being Family leader who truly "ruled" the country.

66. This one makes J'avos, zombies and clones. Though not completely out of place from the rest of the series

68. Not sure how they got through airport security with their guns intact. I guess Leon has some Fake IDs to help him get abroad. And since Simmons declared Leon and Helena as fugitives, i don't think people are that quick to forget the faces of someone who was just declared as dead hour ago.

69. No argument there

70. They certainly made it easier on PS4 and Switch ports.

71. No comment.

72. They look no worse for wear after that except few scratches

73. To play devil's advocate, i don't think he was directly sinning their reunion on itself. But yeah, its awful sin. Why wouldn't Sherry want to make good for the world after what she experienced? But then again, she never had her freedom and due to having bonded with G-virus, she was being tested and turned into agent.

74. For once i would love to see Leon's hair getting messed up and have him react to it

75. That is entirely subjective matter. Just because you like it, doesn't mean everyone else does. For me, its okay

76. To be fair, that was only hidden in Ada's campaign which was initially locked until you play 3 games first. Its been fixed in other ports. In Leon's campaign we are confused but its intentional since its left to Ada's campaign to explain.

77. No comment

78. Chris tried to kill her scene earlier before confrontation, but missed and Piers didn't stop him doing that. He doesn't tell Chris at any point that they need info out of her.

79. Don't think its that dark. You can see light coming out of the window. My theory is that they were too caught up in fighting to not bothering to look who they were and they moved so fast.

80. So she magically summoned a flash grenade?

81. Ok, question. Where is stated that Simmons didn't allow Leon visit her? We know that Claire visited Sherry once in a while and she gave Sherry a warning about Simmons according to the files, while it didn't say anything about Leon visiting her, but it didn't say anything about not allowing him to visit her. Also, Simmons being Sherry's guardian should've been expanded on more imo, because i didn't feel their relationship because it was mostly told, than shown

82. I don't think anyone in right mind would be stupid enough to believe they wouldn't. Although, Simmons's methods were really extreme.

85. They were still in the line of fire. As for the "frustration" part, i dunno.

86. To be fair, i have seen some people miss the second handgun on their first playthrough and some say its not well-explained to you. When i played it first time, i triggered it by accident during beginning

87. No argument on A point. They didn't hear J'avo coming due to all the gunfire. But don't see why they would stop shooting all together if Leon and Helena could be possible hindrance to their plan.

88. More like plot convenience

89. It happens in anime quite alot

90. RE0 has its own issues.

91. Referring to my point 60

92. I personally find quite ridiculous. How are his shoes and pants intact after all that?

93. No comment

94. Is this how you react to people who have different opinion than yours? You love the game, that's great. Its perfectly fine. No need to shove your views down on people's throats. And i'm not defending Dartigan here, his research on the video is extremely poor.

95. Question remains what can and can't C-Virus do exactly

96. I agree

97. No argument there. This scene is kinda cool

98. I think its quite silly how Simmons survives all that shit. I know he has enhanced C-Virus strain, but what are the limitations to it.

99. He is endurable one for sure

100. I guess he is referring "Its not over" cliche

101. No comment

102. Speed zombies has been used in lot of media

103. No comment

104. No comment

105. No argument there

106. Because characters shrugging off things like they are nothing makes the stakes all boring

107. My suspension of disbelief can only go so far

108. I think it would be neat detail to show bandaged up

109. No comment

110. This awfully reminded me of the scene from Independence Day

111. But why was he infected if he was in the helicopter? C-Virus makes zombies by gas, not through bites. Those who inhaled the gas turned almost instantly.

112. I think this outdoes CV in terms of action

113. I guess its matter of taste

114. It explains his transformation, but not much about the mass he produces on his own and can somehow revert back to human. Yes, in the 3rd form he ingests bodies to get bigger.

115. Wait, was C-Virus gas flammable?

116. You see blood splatter from Leon's back when he is hit

117. While explained, it doesn't make it less ridiculous that looks like his final nail in the coffin, only to be revealed alive moments later

118. Though that asks a question. Since when?

119. Yes, its shown. But still quite a convenience that there is lightning storm

120. Would be nice if this detail was shown than told to you via paywall or internet page

121. I'm getting Mortal Kombat memories from this

122. She only said that she "found" the way to defeat virus, but not saying how

123. I'm not expert on US Laws system, but i believe that assisting in President's assassination is gonna be quite severe, she should be at least on suspension for few months and not in prison. Leon could have cleared his name earlier in the story, but chose to stay with Helena.

I want to tell beforehand that this was no meant to attack you or anything. I wanted to give my two cents about the essay explain where i agree and where i disagree

And yes, i think Dartigan is crap and his videos lack proper research. Either he didn't gave a damn or he was just being incompetent.
Interesting. Are you going to do other campaigns? I would like to see your points in regards to other campaigns too.

This is really good!

My video essay response draws from the original essay responses that started this post, however, some of your responses I actually bring up in some of my responses like how I also think it's stupid how the files are unlocked in RE6 and made worse by having critical details missing in-game to have them available online. It backs up the criticism that a story is lazily told or written which is hard to defend when you have conflicts like that. I'm a firm believer that any game should have its story told in full within the game. To my knowledge, Resident Evil 5 didn't require the BSAA emblems to unlock certain Library files and that game had a smaller story in scale compared to 6. More confusion to me why Capcom decided to go that route. Dartigan doesn't get a free pass nevertheless, but yeah, no story details should go missing.

In any case, good responses!
I agree that they should have made re net portions available in the game's files but capcom always hid important details through supplemental materials. I think this is a way for them to increase the mystery of the series' lore. In none of the games, you cant get the full context through playing them alone, you still need to look up somewhere. I like re5's library system but it bothers me that the files found in environment arent saved as collectibles after picking them up. In re6, you shoot serpent emblems to collect the files and ı think this is a very smart system. By decreasing the family's influence, you're rewarded with lore through such a clever storytelling route. When ı 1st played the game, ı remember quite enjoying the story due to cutscenes as well as voice acting and interactions but finding out about the files made me love it even more. It felt like an extra reward, more so after deciding to sign up to re net to see the extended version of them out of curiosity. I would have liked that to carry on to other games. Re engine entries are connected to re net and yet they dont utilize something like that. Instead they go back to outdated file picking up system and even then, the files feel underwhelming compared to re6. Re engine village also has a very important report as a paid dlc and ı dislike that with a passion. It could have been an unlockable either through the game or re net site.
 
"Will you do other campaigns?" Yes, in all due time. I need to refresh my memory on Chris and other campaigns. I do remember
This is really good!

My video essay response draws from the original essay responses that started this post, however, some of your responses I actually bring up in some of my responses like how I also think it's stupid how the files are unlocked in RE6 and made worse by having critical details missing in-game to have them available online. It backs up the criticism that a story is lazily told or written which is hard to defend when you have conflicts like that. I'm a firm believer that any game should have its story told in full within the game. To my knowledge, Resident Evil 5 didn't require the BSAA emblems to unlock certain Library files and that game had a smaller story in scale compared to 6. More confusion to me why Capcom decided to go that route. Dartigan doesn't get a free pass nevertheless, but yeah, no story details should go missing.

In any case, good responses!
Thank you. Now i wanna say that RE6 is not a bad game at all. I will admit that i was harsh on it on its launch. But replaying it again few years later made me appreciate it bit more. Though some of the problems still persists like how the story is told. While gameplay is more fluid compared to other games so credit where its due some areas feel really unpolished for example vehicle sections like Jake on motorcycle. Turning feels really stiff if that is right word to explain it. That being said Dartigan has made lot of mishaps in other videos than just Resident Evil. His Sekiro video for example comes to mind. I gave up on his videos long ago. Thank you for your reply and Merry Xmas 🎄🎄
 
Interesting. Are you going to do other campaigns? I would like to see your points in regards to other campaigns too.


I agree that they should have made re net portions available in the game's files but capcom always hid important details through supplemental materials. I think this is a way for them to increase the mystery of the series' lore. In none of the games, you cant get the full context through playing them alone, you still need to look up somewhere. I like re5's library system but it bothers me that the files found in environment arent saved as collectibles after picking them up. In re6, you shoot serpent emblems to collect the files and ı think this is a very smart system. By decreasing the family's influence, you're rewarded with lore through such a clever storytelling route. When ı 1st played the game, ı remember quite enjoying the story due to cutscenes as well as voice acting and interactions but finding out about the files made me love it even more. It felt like an extra reward, more so after deciding to sign up to re net to see the extended version of them out of curiosity. I would have liked that to carry on to other games. Re engine entries are connected to re net and yet they dont utilize something like that. Instead they go back to outdated file picking up system and even then, the files feel underwhelming compared to re6. Re engine village also has a very important report as a paid dlc and ı dislike that with a passion. It could have been an unlockable either through the game or re net site.
Will i do all other campaigns? Yes, all in due time. I'm gonna playthrough them incase i missed something. Now i see your point about the files on website, but what about the people who don't have access to internet? They are gonna miss crucial key moments from the ga,e. Personally i find it more rewarding to find that stuff in the game itself when you keep digging. Player's hardwork on the game should be rewarded. I was also not fan of RE6 having some interesting character moments happen offscreen but happening in the files on RE.Net. As old saying goes "Show more, tell less" Yes, i agree RE8 is worse than 6 in this regard. WTF Capcom? At least you didn't pay for files in 6. RE8 makes lot of baffling decisions in the story. After all that's said, RE6 is still good time and it gets too much hate. Some stuff i appreciate more than before while some flaws still persist. Is it perfect game? Not at all, but then again is there any game that is perfect? I doubt it. Even RE4 is flawed in many ways than people like to admit. I ain't afraid of critiquing my favourite games and not pretend they are perfect games because they are not. Those are my 2 cents.

Either way, Merry Xmas to you 🎄🎄🎄
 

mert20004

Mert_BIO_6
Will i do all other campaigns? Yes, all in due time. I'm gonna playthrough them incase i missed something. Now i see your point about the files on website, but what about the people who don't have access to internet? They are gonna miss crucial key moments from the ga,e. Personally i find it more rewarding to find that stuff in the game itself when you keep digging. Player's hardwork on the game should be rewarded. I was also not fan of RE6 having some interesting character moments happen offscreen but happening in the files on RE.Net. As old saying goes "Show more, tell less" Yes, i agree RE8 is worse than 6 in this regard. WTF Capcom? At least you didn't pay for files in 6. RE8 makes lot of baffling decisions in the story. After all that's said, RE6 is still good time and it gets too much hate. Some stuff i appreciate more than before while some flaws still persist. Is it perfect game? Not at all, but then again is there any game that is perfect? I doubt it. Even RE4 is flawed in many ways than people like to admit. I ain't afraid of critiquing my favourite games and not pretend they are perfect games because they are not. Those are my 2 cents.

Either way, Merry Xmas to you 🎄🎄🎄
I agree with your points in regards to re4 and re engine but for re6; my issues for it are incredibly small things that ı prefer downplaying, especially how overexaggerated criticisms get. I think the weakest part of the game are extra game modes. If ı wanted something to be cut, it would be them, particularly online dlcs. I think the campaigns along with the amount of lore are the strongest parts of the game and mechanics work better at them than other modes which behave more like redundant practice sessions. The outdated collecting file from environment system only made sense for the very 1st game, after that ı find its execution repetitive. Outbreak games greatly improved from this method and file 2 made commenting at them possible. I wouldnt mind if re6 took a more similar approach to those games but ı still like the execution and finding out about the files felt like a great surprise as a shock factor due to interesting lore within them. The fact that it was the 1st re game ı played helped quite a lot about this.

But anyway it's 24 december here. The video is gonna be available for me at 27 december 02:00. I'll be sleeping during that time but after waking up, ı'll watch it and share my thoughts about the video here. I still cant wait for it, no doubt it's gonna be amazing!
 

mert20004

Mert_BIO_6

Finally the video ı was excited for is released. I fully watched it as of now and ı have to say... This is one of the best re6 videos ı've ever seen. Seriously. I've never seen anyone else defending and praising the game's story through such an excellent and informative format before. It's quite long and very entertaining. Felt like a very high quality movie. I absolutely loved watching this, it's everything ı was expecting for and even better! Definitely one of the best re6 videos on youtube right next to " Why re6 is awesome? " one by tgbs.

Thank you so much for this omegablackheart! I really appreciate the effort put into this. I had no doubt about the amazingness of this perfect masterpiece and it delivered very well. Good luck with your next project as always. Personally the next entry ı'm interested for your counterpoint is dartigan's recv video since he rushed that on a whim just to give re engine 4's existence an excuse.
 
Last edited:

Finally the video ı was excited for is released. I fully watched it as of now and ı have to say... This is one of the best re6 videos ı've ever seen. Seriously. I've never seen anyone else defending and praising the game's story through such an excellent and informative format before. It's quite long and very entertaining. Felt like a very high quality movie. I absolutely loved watching this, it's everything ı was expecting for and even better! Definitely one of the best re6 videos on youtube right next to " Why re6 is awesome? " one by tgbs.

Thank you so much for this omegablackheart! I really appreciate the effort put into this. I had no doubt about the amazingness of this perfect masterpiece and it delivered very well. Good luck with your next project as always. Personally the next entry ı'm interested for your counterpoint is dartigan's recv video since he rushed that on a whim just to give re engine 4's existence an excuse.
Thank you very much for the positive comments and continual guidance on the project, Mert 😎👍🏼

Happy to know you loved how this turned out and hope others enjoy it as well.
 
Ok, since the Youtube couldn't let me send my comment even though i tried to polite and respectful as possible, i thought i share this reply here

Hoo boy, here we go...Note: This is not meant to be insult to you nor Dartigan-defense response(He gets lot of wrong in this video game which he does frequently in other videos as well)

Sin 1: No comment
Sin 2: It is iconic, but for once i would like to see him with
Sin 3: Actually, zombies looking over the shoulder happens twice in this game. 1. with Adam zombie. 2. if you get killed by zombie before resulting game over screen
Sin 4: I think it comes off with the execution of that scene particular. The way Leon pleads with zombified President that can easily come off as Leon being "inexperienced" in this instead of not wanting to accept reality. It is understandable why Leon would hesitate, though. Another problem is that we are introduced to this Adam character and he is already a zombie at the point so it's hard to feel any attachment to him for many people. They should have had more scenes together to substantiate their friendship and leading to tragic end instead of just one minute flashback(One thing Infinite Darkness show could have done was to show Adam with Leon) I am aware that its explained in the files how they are friends and champions of similar causes and him possibly being the guy in Leon's epilogue who coerced him into working for US Government in RE3 Epilogue. That detail should not be overlooked.
Sin 5-10: I guess he was referring to Helena saying "Its all my fault" without elaborating on why she is at fault. But yeah, i agree overall
Sin 10-20: No argument there, but i can only excuse her not telling Leon this time only
Sin 21: No comment there
Sin 22: No argument there
Sin 23: Due to how long Covid has been around, its not farfetched
Sin 24: The game isn't as horrendous as Dartigan as claims(Though oddly he considers RE5 worse than this), but this game ain't sinless either
Sin 25: I can see your point, but Leon just witnessed his best friend turn into zombie minutes ago. You would think he would be suspect possible infection. Granted, it is the new type of virus this time, but still. I'm not advocating that Leon should have shot the man and his daughter immediately after seeing them, Leon is not that type of person. But he doesn't do much to deal with the situation. Even Damnation he was screaming at soldiers to not get close to infected old man which took place before RE6.
Sin 26: No argument there
Sin 27: I do find it funny that Leon says that jacking cars is not as easy as in the movies and key is conveniently placed inside sun visor
Sin 28: Or he could have just gathered more speed and stop the car, causing zombies to fall off from the roof unless the road was very tight and he didn't have enough space, then yes i see your point
Sin 29: I'm no expert on cars and explosions, but i think engine wouldn't explode that easily without leaking and set on fire. Also, later the BSAA soldier to comes to aid Leon and Helena with jeep and it gets flipped over and he dies inside while the engine catches on fire.
Sin 30: I see your point, but light flashing at someone's eyes does sting quite a bit
Sin 31: I agree. Imagine a horror game without sewer level
Sin 32: Granted, Helena did not know what was going underground as she later states that none of the lab equipment were there few days ago.
Sin 33: Again, i see your point. Still, wished there was more to them than just this one flashback to substantiate their friendship.
Sin 34: No argument there. I think it was plot point in one of the CGI Re movies as well.
Sin 35: No argument there
Sin 386: No argument there
Sin 87: It is used on movies alot
Sin 88: No comment
Sin 89: I know it comes down to personal preference, but the reason why i found cabin defense scene in RE4 so nerve wracking was due to fighting infected in tight places(Not saying RE4 is flawless masterpiece when its not). While RE6's "cabin defense" is bigger than RE4s, but you are given more ways to deal with enemies with more variety of melee attacks more than in RE4.
Sin 90: Um, Brad Vickers for abandoning the team in the forest? Nah, i'm just kidding. The problem with the survivor, Peter is that he is literal sociopath for abandoning his OWN GIRLFRIEND to zombies and how she just slows him down. Even Larry from Walking Dead looks like saint compared to him.
Sin 91: Predictable death, but it introduces Blood shots in the game
Sin 92: No argument there, although the old man doesn't tell em this.
Sin 93: Its a quite coincidence though, especially when there is no way out of the Cathedral aside from the underground tunnel
Sin 94: Dunno if everyone uses them, but plausible.
Sin 95: When i saw this for the first time, i thought it was Boomer from Left 4 Dead XD
Sin 94: Though why didn't hear the ground shake when Whopper got close? It could be argued that they were too distracted on getting out ASAP.
Sin 95: I think it was 90% of the population was estimated to have been infected
Sin 100: To be fair, Neo-Umbrella is not that clever name though
Sin 105: No argument there. It was the only lead they had
Sin 106: To be fair, Simmons looks like villain material in first glance.
Sin 107: They should've known not to drive high speed during rainstorm though. And whether it is character mistake or not, we are not free from being sinners, but that doesn't make us bad people.
Sin 108: I see your point, but it is still quite coincidence. Though bigger question is why Leon and Helena survived that fallwithout breaking at least one bone in their bodies.
Sin 109: I admit it is tasteless joke, but i'm pretty sure Bus wouldn't be this easily explosive
Sin 110: Personal opinion, not very good one at when the game gives you marker where to go every time. Granted, i'd probably had issues if you have to look everywhere to find the dog.
Sin 111: No argument there. Besides, rescue workers would probably come with full team than just two people
Sin 112: While i understand Helena's point, it is still kinda BS. At least tell Leon that her sister is being held captive, i'm pretty sure Leon would've likely helped Helena to rescue her sister and gone to the underground anyway. I think Leon is smart enough to not dismiss anything what Helena tells him after been through so much already. Besides, if we take Infinite Darkness into account which took place chronologically 6-7 years before RE6, conspiracy stuff or corrupted government officials using viruses for their own personal gain or motivation isn't a new thing in this series.
Sin 113: No argument there. Its a new virus
Sin 114: Yes, collecting files in this game is quite dumb. Especially when the most crucial key moments are hidden behind RE.NET website and are not accessible in the game itself. From what i gathered, Lepotitsa/Lepotica's were sent into the campus by Simmons and after spreading gas everywhere they self-destruct themselves, but we never see them doing this in the game itself. It also doesn't help that some of character moments in this game fell flat for me, because the files you found on website reveal more insight on the characters and their motivations, but are hardly discussed in the game itself. Like Deborah's final letter to her sister for example. Can you imagine how impactful it would've been had Helena found her sister's letter, telling how much she loves her after dealing with her in a boss fight?
Sin 115: I know someone quite well that has VHS player even to this day.
Sin 116: I do question Dartigan's taste in porn though
Sin 117: Referring to Sin 116. Only thing we see is her boobs
Sin 118: Possible, though not explained
Sin 119: Its possible. Though why don't Leon and Helena take video tape with them? That has clear evidence on Simmons by just looking at his hand with ring on it with Family Insignia? I guess it could be argued that Leon was too shooked by the revelation
Sin 120: No comment
Sin 130: Yes, shooting Helena would be extremely extreme for Leon to do. But why is it so difficult to tell someone their family member is in danger? I get that Helena was probably racing a clock and wanted to get to Deborah as soon as possible which is understandable, but also quite frustrating.
Sin 131: To be fair, this was before the place started collapsing
Sin 132: Brzak and traps? I get it, but place suddenly collapsing is quite convenient. Although, chalk it up to place slowly collapsing due it being around for centuries.
Sin 133: This boss fight looks pretty...suggestive
Sin 134: No argument there. Then again, we have Tyrants that walk around naked and they don't have...you know
Sin 135: That shot has been used in various movies
Sin 137: Referring to Sin 130
Sin 138: There is also Del Lago in RE4 and Irving's boss battle in RE5
Sin 139: Initially i thought Mines of Moria joke was funny, but this ain't a sin. If he was referring that RE6 is plagiarizing the Lord of the Rings, then by his logic every video game is plagiarizing others.
Sin 140: Another pointless sin from Dartigan
Sin 141: It was quite convenience that it had harpoon attached to it somehow, unless i missed something in the game.
Sin 142: No comment
Sin 143: Not a shark, although they admitted they designed Brzak after Bull shark.
Sin 144: Scene itself is quite silly though. Then again, RE has had multiple ridiculous stuff in it
Sin 145: I admit, i initially missed that mutant fish was actually based on human, but it still looks shark to me. Even then, mutant fish from human or not, fish don't have vocal chords, unless it has specific biology that allows it.
Sin 146: No comment
Sin 147: This detail of the nuclear bomb has been quite contradictory to the series. RE archives claim its nuclear while Biohazard archives and Kawamura claim its thermobaric, though with the case of RE archives could be translation error. As for sterilization of the city, i'm not expert on politics, but i recall that direct confirmation has to come from The President before you launch a nuke. Although, Simmons had influence in this
Sin 148: This one creates intelligence mutants, zombies and even clones. Though it could be argued CV was the first game to introduce the cloning of Ashfords but it was more subtle.
Sin 149: No argument there
Sin 150: Yes, she faked their deaths, but considering how she declared them dead just few hours ago i don't think people are that quick to forget faces. Especially when Face recognition has been a thing since 2010 and this game takes place in 2013. Of course, if that happened then the game would likely ended there.
Sin 151. To be fair, that detail is only found on RE.NET and not in the game itself. Which to be honest, is one of the bad ways you can tell your story. Still better than RE8, though
Sin 152: I guess it comes with the personal preference on QTEs. They certainly made this scene easier in PS4 port.
Sin 153: I guess he mistook the way scene was handled as Leon seeing Ada or something, i dunno.
Sin 154: I like to believe their injuries would be worse than what is shown.
Sin 165: I don't think he was sinning the reunion on itself, but yeah his reasoning is dumb. Unless, you count Outbreak cast some of them went on with their lives
Sin 166: It would be funny to see Leon's hair messed up once.
Sin 167: I can conclude that line he thinks is dumb i guess
Sin 169: I'm guessing he was very nonchalant about the whole and didn't care about finding out.
Sin 168: Ok, that was pretty funny.
Sin 169: But he also doesn't stop Chris from trying to kill her nor tells him that they need valuable info out of her.
Sin 269: The fight itself is cool, although i don't think its that dark to see.
Sin 270: Granted, i think with characters being thrown into the dangerous situations are properly equipped, except for Carla who is running in a skirt, then again Ada wore dress in RE4
Sin 271: Problem is once again that Capcom stored that detail of Sherry and Simmons's relationship into the background files in Extra features. We don't get to know and see their relationship unfold.
Sin 272: No comment
Sin 277: No comment
Sin 279: I have no words
Sin 280: I do find it funny that they don't stop firing once Leon and Helena ducked in the cover, but keep shooting at the same location where Jake and Sherry were only to be stopped by Simmons.
Sin 281: I accidentally triggered it on accident
Sin 291: No argument on the J'avo sneaking up on Simmons, but they were clearly stairs next to the platform so its not like they couldn't have followed them.
Sin 292: Convenient time for speeding train
Sin 293: Crushing something in anger has been quite cliche especially in anime
Sin 294: To me it looks like action setpiece of Michael Bay movie instead of something like Speed or Mission Impossible
Sin 295: Sadly, most of Simmons's motives are only explained in background files and vaguely hinted at in the game.
Sin 296: Transformers-Simmons
Sin 297: No argument on unrealism in the series. But what are exactly the limitations to the C-Virus?
Sin 298: It is quite over-the-top, though.
Sin 299: No comment
Sin 300: Can't believe Dartigan missed that part where you have to shoot Simmons to make him trip and he couldn't build enough speed and velocity to derail the train where Leon and Helena were on.
Sin 310: It is cool scene, realism be damned
Sin 311: I can only conclude that he thought Helena shooting Simmons in the head made more damage than getting hit by train earlier
Sin 312: I am aware of the effects of enhanced C-Virus, but it gets ridiculous to the point when the game pretends that it's gonna be the end of Simmons only to appear alive moments later.
Sin 313: No argument there
Sin 314: No comment
Sin 315: It comes to personal preference over all and i love Dawn of the Dead Remake. Also in Leon's report in RE6, he says that these zombies are more faster and more agile than zombies in RE2.
Sin 316: Good point
Sin 316: Admittedly, character models are done fantastically here minus some of the NPCs. As for Leon and Ada, of course he would be shocked even if this isn't the first time he thought she died.
Sin 317: Sure, but it is quite convenient that Leon runs into trucks
Sin 318: Plot armor defies all logic
Sin 328: Um...no. Because if you go to Cutscenes section where they have placed the timeline for each cutscenes. Then yes, the scenes where Helena gets injured and has to be patched by Leon happens between scenes where they get knocked back by explosion and facing against Simmons again later on.
Sin 329: I am getting Independence Day flashbacks from this scene
Sin 330: Question is how did he get infected? We learn through Marhawa Desire that zombies that C-Virus creates do not infect through bites, but by gas. And if this guy was on the helicopter the entire time, how did he get infected, but not his partner?
Sin 335: Michael Bay comment is bit overkill, but i can "sort" of see his point due to how over the top action is in this game
Sin 336: No comment
Sin 337: I do question how Simmons is able to not transform to T-Rex, but also revert back to his Hellhound form and also turn back to human? What are the rules on C-Virus anymore?
Sin 338: But we didn't see any J'avo in Leon's campaign aside from the one who shot Simmons and this takes way long after the first mission with Chris.
Sin 339: You can clearly see blood splatter from Leon's back when Simmons shoots him with bones
Sin 340: I understand the effects, but its still silly how they keep faking him possibly dying only reveal he is alive minutes later.
Sin 341: I'm guessing they keep numbers with each other
Sin 346: While its explained in Ada's campaign, but lightning storm was really convenient in order them to severely damage Simmons
Sin 347: I do find it funny after been disintegrated, he still has enough to revert back to human
Sin 348: Writers and their tricks. But in all seriousness, if we are gonna use "Because writer says so" as defense, then does that mean we should stop critiquing movies like Sharknado because it was intentionally made bad?
Sin 349: While she says they can defeat the virus, but don't clarify how after all the break loose in Tachi.
Sin 350: I'm not expert on US laws, but having hand in President's murder is gonna be quite severe whether she pulled the trigger or not. I can't exactly confirm it, but at worse she should be on suspension for few months instead in prison for life as Dartigan claims
Sin 351: I'm guessing he is referring to game not specifying in which part of Eastern Europe
Sin 356: This is gonna sound complicated if not controversial. First and foremost, i wanna say that i love the idea on Chris reaching his breaking point and possibly suffer PTSD from all the men he lost and after what he's been through which is understandable. I wanted to appreciate it, but some issues lies in execution. For 1: His PTSD fueled amnesia only lasts in single chapter and afterwards he keeps running off recklessly trying to take down Carla and being jerk to everyone. 2: The game kinda glosses over on what he's been doing in 6 months which is only touched upon in the files. 3. While its understandable why Chris is so pissed and not in his right mind, but in some scenes he comes off as incredibly petty and kinda childish as i get into later. 4. It kinda undermines his growth in RE5 in which the game starts with Chris with more cynical outlook on life due to how losing Jill took toll on him(and learning info about her was his only hope) and questions if his fighting and hardwork all are worth it anymore. But, at the end of the game, after Wesker's defeat and getting Jill back, Chris has now regained his hope for the world and has gained new sense of purpose of fighting for the better future. Yes, the flashback chapter on Edonia does this seem head to the direction where RE5 ended with Chris becoming captain of the squad and leading a new squad which was great touch. But that is quickly over during the end of the chapter and Chris becomes amnesiac whose haunted by guilt he can't remember(according to the files) so he runs away and spends his time drinking at the bar for whole 6 months. RE5 started out with Chris is dark place, but regained new sense of hope at the end of the game only to lose it again at the time of RE6 with difference being adding Post-Traumatic Amnesia to the mix. Not saying that this couldn't happen to Chris, because it can, but i kinda felt disappointed that it makes Chris's arc and struggles in RE5 feel bit redundant. This is the case when it would have been better for Jill to come back to pull Chris out of brink like how Chris freed Jill from being mind-controlled for over 3 years in the last game, but she is not even mentioned in the game or in game files or RE.NET files. It is explained in Revelations 2 where Jill was doing, but that was like 3 years too late as Revelations 2 game came after RE6's release.
Sin: 357: How many steroid jokes has Dartigan made in his videos?
Sin: 358-363: No argument there
Sin: 364: No argument there
Sin: 365: It does bring in question how much Chris does remember. Does he still remember Claire or Jill after regaining his memory? And come to think of it, where was Jill and Claire when Chris went missing for 6 months. I know that it was mentioned in Revelations 2 but that game came 3 years too late since RE6 was released
Sin: 366: He does blame himself for failing to save Richard in RE1 Remake, although it turns out to be Wesker's fault when Chris finds out. While Chris wasn't the leader of S.T.A.R.S, he obviously cared about them and the reason why he went to investigate Umbrella and find ways to bring them down was because of the honor of his fallen S.T.A.R.S members. While yes, leading the team on your own adds much bigger responsibility, but sadly, most of Chris's men feel like cannon fodder thrown into the meat grinder than proper characters.
Sin 367: I can see Piers means well, but pulling the amnesiac PTSD-ridden soldier back on the field without psychic evaluation is one of the worst decisions you could make. Yes, Chris has the reputation of thwarting many outbreaks and bioterrorist attacks, but he is clearly not in his right mind to make rational calls or could lose himself to anger as he does once he regains memory about his teammates and Carla, whom he mistakens as Ada.
Sin 368: As i said in earlier post
Sin 369: No argument there
Sin 370: No comment
Sin 371: No argument there. I'm guessing Dartigan skipped all the files in previous RE games as well
Sin 372: Wished the game would explore some of the ramifications on C-Virus and what are its limits, because it can basically do anything
Sin 373: Don't think body armor protects you enough from RPG warhead that would penetrate human body and even if it didn't penetrate the armor, the explosion itself would be big enough to 100% kill human
Sin 378: No comment
Sin 379: Because in good action movies explosions and falling debris happen for reason and not randomly?
Sin 380: It still doesn't explain why are they bombing the building clear of all the J'avo. Unless, they were worried it could still have more inside somewhere.
Sin 385: If John McClane survived boat explosion with mere inches away from him, don't see why Chris wouldn't survive this. Although, realistically, they would suffer from severe 2nd and 3rd degree burns at best.
Sin 386: No argument there. Although, triggering flashback has been thing in movies alot and people call it cliche
Sin 387: No comment
Sin 388: Although in Leon's case, most vehicles get crashed or blown up quite often during his campaign. Some due to his driving skills and some out of his control.
Sin 389: I think most of us wanted to climb on that thing to get cool and stylish kill than just shoot it
Sin 390: Finn seems like a typical fanboy archetype i have seen in all sorts of media before. At least he didn't turn evil
Sin 391-400: Guess he forgot that scene when he was making the script, but yeah, that scene was still quite ridiculous.
Sin 401-406: Maybe, but writers aren't immune to criticism.
Sin 407: I'm sorry, but you are forgetting that Ada was mentioned in RE1 as part of puzzle in John's diary.
Sin 408: No comment
Sin 409-418: No argument there. Although so far we have had organizations like Umbrella, its rival company called "Third Organization but don't think they intentionally wanted to spread around the virus. Aside from what you just listed, we also have the terrorist group in Degeneration, although the film quite implies it was all Tricell's doing and Arias's attempt to infect population in Vendetta(although that took place after RE6)
Sin 419: I do wonder how it works though.
Sin 420: No argument there
Sin 430: No complaints about RCS's performance. He did fantastic job and he will always be the definitive Chris Redfield for me. Buuuut...it pains me to say this, but Finn didn't grow enough for me to care about him. He does have good qualities in him, he is kindhearted rookie who wants to do good and is excited to work with Chris whose he is fanboying over. But other than that, there is not much to him. Sure, in the files we learn that he had mother back at States, but his character failed to captivate me.
Sin 431: From what it looked like, it look like dead end corridor and i don't want to use theories as irrefutable fact even if its good theory.
Sin 432: Granted, Nicholai was not much of a boss fight as you take him down with single rocket. In RE6 it's a boss fight and it takes ridiculous amount of damage.
Sin 433: No argument there, although i do like Yawn fight
Sin 434: Well given the state that Chris was in, Piers should have known better than that that Chris likely wasn't fit to lead the unit.
Sin 435: No argument there.
Sin 436: Not sure on why she would want to torment Chris so badly when her main goal is to make Simmons suffer. Unless, Carla is really sadist which is likely true.
Sin 437: I agree, although i think Dartigan should be blaming Piers for deaths of the first team by his logic. Chris is the one that specifically ordered Piers to not let Carla out of sight and he does. My point is that they were probably too busy in fighting that they didn't notice her disappear.
Sin 438: Since one of the signs of being infected with C-Virus make your body combust. I'm surprised C4 didn't ignite and blow up.
Sin 439: Mythbusters got you covered
Sin 444: No comment
Sin 449: No comment
Sin 454: No comment on the laugh. Granted, Chris is being quite petty here. Yes, i am aware of him wanting revenge, but he really makes himself look like fool here. Maybe it was done intentionally, but still
Sin 453: No argument there. Also what irritates me is that you can stuck on invisible wall at the moment
Sin 553: I like this scene overall, however my issue with this scene how Chris's change here felt little too sudden for me. Chapter 3 reinforces that Chris and Piers have conflicting goals and they spend majority of Chapter 3 arguing about the mission and what's right. You would think there would've been some payoff to their conflict later on in the story, but after one pep talk from Leon, Chris is almost immediately becomes nice with Piers. I do like that Chris is finally taking some responsibility from his actions, but i felt the the game took the easy way out for their conflict.
Sin 554: No comment. Although, arrogance has been used in almost every bad guy in these games
Sin 555: No comment
Sin 556: No argument there
Sin 561: Meh
Sin 562: Because of course
Sin 563: It does activate, but still with countdown.
Sin 568: No comment
Sin 570: Meh
Sin 571: Irony perhaps. Deep? Arguable
Sin 572: The amount of times this game tries to play every silly stuff seriously, it comes off as often as unintentionally hilarious.
Sin 573: Dartigan's hate boner for Chris is very apparent.
Sin 574: Jake grew up in Europe, its likely he learned American Accent during his time as mercenary.
Sin 575: Also Chris tells Piers that despite Wesker deserving what he got that he was still Jake's father and he needed to know. I was also wrong about this, even though the scene is bit too overdramatic for my taste when i get to later. But i can understand why Chris spilled his beans.
Sin 574: I'm actually one of the people who still passionately love RE5
Sin 575: No argument there
Sin 576: I'd like to ask someone who works in a place like this
SIn 577: I think Piers getting his right arm impaled and crushed was simple coincidence as HAOS grabbed what was nearest to it and Piers's right arm was the closest to it.
Sin 578: No argument there
Sin 579: To be fair, the file about HAOS is only excluded in RE.NET and not in game itself. It was also said that once Carla's vital signs cease to function, her group will initiate Plan D to unleash HAOS whether its incomplete or not. Which explains that had Leon not interfered Chris at that moment, Haos would have been released as soon as Chris shot her death and no one would be able to stop it in time.
Sin 580: No argument there
Sin 581: No comment
Sin 582: I agree that it should have had cameo on Jill. Also why go to the exact place where he started in? I get that its supposed to be symbolic Book end scene, but still.
Sin 583: That's neat detail, but how would Jake know that lullaby
Sin 584: Apple joke is overused
Sin 585: No argument there
Sin 586: If someone with many eyes stared at me i would be like "The heck, man?"
Sin 591: No comment
Sin 592: We don't know
Sin 593: I understand with Jake though
Sin 594: I don't think Chrysalid virus was ever said in the game, but only in the files.
Sin 595: No argument there
Sin 596: Granted, on the launch you wouldn't know this detail until you completed all 3 campaigns. But yeah, i agree overall. Though the files don't really explain how Carla got hold on Wesker's DNA. Sure, it could be single strand of Wesker's hair she obtained.
Sin 597: No argument there, although Jake stumbles quite a bit on his run.
Sin 598: No argument there. Although, even Spiderman would get damaged from explosion.
Sin 599: Ustanak had great potential, but i think he fails to be scary as Nemesis for the fact that you are constantly put into mandatory fights with him where you kick his ass(Minus, the hide n seek section which was pretty good) whereas with Nemesis it was more fight or flight situation, leaving only 3 mandatory fights with him. Nemesis also has tendency to randomly show up to ruin your day and you can feel his presence close with music changing and hearing his voice from distant and that was terrifying. However, i will say i love Ustanak's design and attaching claw or any other kind of weapon to his missing arm makes him formidable enemy.
Sin 600: On first glance i can see why some may not see it due to their different hairstyles, but on closer look they do kinda resemble each other.
Sin 605: "A**holes eat apples" joke again
Sin 606: No argument there, its great set up for his character, although i have some problems with some of the execution
Sin 607: I agree
Sin 608: Considering how far Ustanak can jump, its not too impossible.
Sin 609: It looked like explosion gave him boost
Sin 614: It does look quite ridiculous how one moment Ustanak has giant claw, but when he goes off camera for about 2 seconds, he has freaking minigun attached to his arm.
Sin 615: No comment
Sin 616: 🤷‍♂
Sin 617: No comment on his life...
Sin 618: Unfortunately, her healing factor does not add much beyond Chapter 2.
Sin 619: I think its the scenery that looks kinda romantic and judging what we see throughout the game there are clear signs of implying romance between Jake and Sherry. I do like Sherry's story about the past events and Leon and Claire.
Sin 620: No argument there
Sin 630: No comment
Sin 631: I do like the "Sins of the Fathers" aspect from Jake and Sherry, but i am still questioning Wesker's lineage because this comes up way after his death.
Sin 632: It is Resident Evil game, but i dislike vehicle sections in this game
Sin 633: No comment
Sin 638: Again...no comment
Sin 639: I think people who would work at mines would wear different outfit than just T-shirt
Sin 640: I agree, plus Ustanak is big guy. He wouldn't slip by through tight corridor.
Sin 641: No argument there, although its funny on dying state Sherry says she can't regenerate fast enough. So...yeah. Another point is how he didn't sin Jake being hit by Ustanak's power drill to the face. That would leave some serious injuries to the head and i get that Jake has similar powers as his father, but Wesker wasn't impervious to knives either as Sheva stabbed him in the wrist with knife in RE5.
Sin 642: My only question with this scene is how can Carla walk around in a skirt with her bare legs exposed in a cold weather? At least Sherry seemed wearing right gear for winter.
Sin 643: Granted, it is not explicitly said on how many times he has tried this. And also he only disarmed one armed guy when he had two armed guys still aiming their guns at him. They could have shot Jake right there in there, unless they need him alive. Also, how come Jake's hair hasn't grown in 6 months?
Sin 644: Not really, because they send a FREAKING TANK against them.
Sin 645: No comment
Sin 650: I think there are more pressing issues on Dartigan's video than just spelling errors. Because if i were to count every misspelled line from him, i would be here all day.
Sin 651: No comment
Sin 652: No comment again
Sin 702: Its highly convenient how those clothes in those lockers fit with them perfectly.
Sin 703: No argument there
Sin 704: Even in fictional universe, there needs to be established rules.
Sin 705: No argument there
Sin 706: No comment
Sin 711: I have no words
Sin 712: While tank maneuvers slowly, how does Jake know the tank would miss the shot?
Sin 717: Not a big fan on motorcycle sequence in this game
Sin 723: First of all, maneuvering motorcycle in this game is really stiff and hard to maneuver and one of the reasons i think vehicle sections suck in this game
Sin 724: No comment
Sin 733: Oh boy
Sin 734: To be honest, i thought this was one of the not-so-good moments in Jake's campaign mainly due to how stiff the controls were
Sin 735: No argument there
Sin 736: Fighting unkillable enemies can become tiresome when overused and frustrated when having to constantly fight the thing which it did for me.
Sin 737: No comment
Sin 738: No comment
Sin 739: No argument there.
Sin 740: Not defending Dartigan here, but even i have sometimes trouble with spelling names of some of these monsters in the game like Lepotitsa(which is why i call them Lepotica), Brzak or Rasklapanje
Sin 741: No argument there
Sin 742: I guess
Sin 743: No comment
Sin 744: Ok, first of all, Jake doesn't fully allude to this in the game. He talks about his father 2 times in the whole game minus the encounter. 1. Where he blames him for inheriting his blood and abandoning. 2. When he asks Sherry if Chris knew Wesker was his father which could also seen as Jake being simply curious. And most of their journey has been Jake and Sherry about making the cure out of Jake's blood than search for Wesker. We don't get much what Jake is truly feeling about his father and it often comes off to people that Jake's anger at Chris being too sudden. Jake's feelings are mostly touched in the files and now i can say why i dislike how files are collected in this game. They leave out crucial character moments, one of them being Jake inner thoughts about Wesker which should have been included in the game itself. Another in-game file is about Jake's mother's final letter to her son in which seems to imply that Jake not only wanted to confront his father, but also wanted to honor his mom's last wishes which makes Jake's anger at Chris perfectly justifiable. But, this is not alluded in the game at all. Jake never mentions anything about that. So yeah...he has good development, but it is fumbled by sloppy execution and it pains me to say it.
Sin 745: No argument there.
Sin 746: No comment
Sin 751: RE5 is pretty awesome
Sin 752: No argument there
Sin 753: No argument there
Sin 754: Best boss in the game
Sin 755: Its silly, but cool
Sin 756: Even the files say who funded Neo-Umbrella is unknown
Sin 757: Its explained, but its highly convenient
Sin 762: No comment
Sin 763: Once again, no comment.
Sin 764: Dunno
Sin 769: Well, its true actually
Sin 770: No comment
Sin 771: I do question on how that works exactly
Sin 772: No argument there
Sin 782: No argument here either
Sin 783: Meh
Sin 784: Carla is one crazy woman
Sin 785: But Agent is barely a character and can't do anything until Ada proceeds. And while we get more behind the scenes of the events that we didn't see before, there are parts where i felt the game drags during her campaign.
Sin 786: If this virus can create zombies, mutants, insects and clones, then what are the limitations to it?
Sin 787: How do you know if its impossible to happen someday in the future? Not saying it will, but still.
Sin 788: No argument there
Sin 789: He was in Raccoon City, yes, but left before the outbreak happened in the city.
Sin 790: No comment
Sin 800: Silly dialogue has been franchise's sin from the very first game. It doesn't get pass here either.
Sin 801: I have no words.
Sin 802: I heard original intention for Damnation was to have love story between Leon and Ada, but Capcom refused that. And sadly this is the last time we see Leon and Ada together in upcoming games and movies.
Sin 803: I can only think Ada had a hunch that Leon might need it.
Sin 804: I think the real sin with this game is teasing for character in future games that does not appear in over next 10 years.

Phew, finally i'm done with this. It took me long to make this response and i needed to take breaks to calm down.
First and foremost, i wanna tell you that you put so much effort in this video and you certainly explained everything
well in lot of detail in this video so great job on that. This response was meant to be merely my counterpoint to your video on which points i agree and which i disagree with. I do think Dartigan has poor research on video games, but i find it hard to take him seriously or believe everything what he says. I will say i understand the frustration on people overhating RE6. It is quite overhated game and it does deserve credit where its due, but still it's not untouchable masterpiece that can never be critiqued or analyzed as some say. I think people are entitled to love or dislike RE6 as long as both parties are respectful to each other's point of view.
 

mert20004

Mert_BIO_6
Ok, since the Youtube couldn't let me send my comment even though i tried to polite and respectful as possible, i thought i share this reply here

Hoo boy, here we go...Note: This is not meant to be insult to you nor Dartigan-defense response(He gets lot of wrong in this video game which he does frequently in other videos as well)

Sin 1: No comment
Sin 2: It is iconic, but for once i would like to see him with
Sin 3: Actually, zombies looking over the shoulder happens twice in this game. 1. with Adam zombie. 2. if you get killed by zombie before resulting game over screen
Sin 4: I think it comes off with the execution of that scene particular. The way Leon pleads with zombified President that can easily come off as Leon being "inexperienced" in this instead of not wanting to accept reality. It is understandable why Leon would hesitate, though. Another problem is that we are introduced to this Adam character and he is already a zombie at the point so it's hard to feel any attachment to him for many people. They should have had more scenes together to substantiate their friendship and leading to tragic end instead of just one minute flashback(One thing Infinite Darkness show could have done was to show Adam with Leon) I am aware that its explained in the files how they are friends and champions of similar causes and him possibly being the guy in Leon's epilogue who coerced him into working for US Government in RE3 Epilogue. That detail should not be overlooked.
Sin 5-10: I guess he was referring to Helena saying "Its all my fault" without elaborating on why she is at fault. But yeah, i agree overall
Sin 10-20: No argument there, but i can only excuse her not telling Leon this time only
Sin 21: No comment there
Sin 22: No argument there
Sin 23: Due to how long Covid has been around, its not farfetched
Sin 24: The game isn't as horrendous as Dartigan as claims(Though oddly he considers RE5 worse than this), but this game ain't sinless either
Sin 25: I can see your point, but Leon just witnessed his best friend turn into zombie minutes ago. You would think he would be suspect possible infection. Granted, it is the new type of virus this time, but still. I'm not advocating that Leon should have shot the man and his daughter immediately after seeing them, Leon is not that type of person. But he doesn't do much to deal with the situation. Even Damnation he was screaming at soldiers to not get close to infected old man which took place before RE6.
Sin 26: No argument there
Sin 27: I do find it funny that Leon says that jacking cars is not as easy as in the movies and key is conveniently placed inside sun visor
Sin 28: Or he could have just gathered more speed and stop the car, causing zombies to fall off from the roof unless the road was very tight and he didn't have enough space, then yes i see your point
Sin 29: I'm no expert on cars and explosions, but i think engine wouldn't explode that easily without leaking and set on fire. Also, later the BSAA soldier to comes to aid Leon and Helena with jeep and it gets flipped over and he dies inside while the engine catches on fire.
Sin 30: I see your point, but light flashing at someone's eyes does sting quite a bit
Sin 31: I agree. Imagine a horror game without sewer level
Sin 32: Granted, Helena did not know what was going underground as she later states that none of the lab equipment were there few days ago.
Sin 33: Again, i see your point. Still, wished there was more to them than just this one flashback to substantiate their friendship.
Sin 34: No argument there. I think it was plot point in one of the CGI Re movies as well.
Sin 35: No argument there
Sin 386: No argument there
Sin 87: It is used on movies alot
Sin 88: No comment
Sin 89: I know it comes down to personal preference, but the reason why i found cabin defense scene in RE4 so nerve wracking was due to fighting infected in tight places(Not saying RE4 is flawless masterpiece when its not). While RE6's "cabin defense" is bigger than RE4s, but you are given more ways to deal with enemies with more variety of melee attacks more than in RE4.
Sin 90: Um, Brad Vickers for abandoning the team in the forest? Nah, i'm just kidding. The problem with the survivor, Peter is that he is literal sociopath for abandoning his OWN GIRLFRIEND to zombies and how she just slows him down. Even Larry from Walking Dead looks like saint compared to him.
Sin 91: Predictable death, but it introduces Blood shots in the game
Sin 92: No argument there, although the old man doesn't tell em this.
Sin 93: Its a quite coincidence though, especially when there is no way out of the Cathedral aside from the underground tunnel
Sin 94: Dunno if everyone uses them, but plausible.
Sin 95: When i saw this for the first time, i thought it was Boomer from Left 4 Dead XD
Sin 94: Though why didn't hear the ground shake when Whopper got close? It could be argued that they were too distracted on getting out ASAP.
Sin 95: I think it was 90% of the population was estimated to have been infected
Sin 100: To be fair, Neo-Umbrella is not that clever name though
Sin 105: No argument there. It was the only lead they had
Sin 106: To be fair, Simmons looks like villain material in first glance.
Sin 107: They should've known not to drive high speed during rainstorm though. And whether it is character mistake or not, we are not free from being sinners, but that doesn't make us bad people.
Sin 108: I see your point, but it is still quite coincidence. Though bigger question is why Leon and Helena survived that fallwithout breaking at least one bone in their bodies.
Sin 109: I admit it is tasteless joke, but i'm pretty sure Bus wouldn't be this easily explosive
Sin 110: Personal opinion, not very good one at when the game gives you marker where to go every time. Granted, i'd probably had issues if you have to look everywhere to find the dog.
Sin 111: No argument there. Besides, rescue workers would probably come with full team than just two people
Sin 112: While i understand Helena's point, it is still kinda BS. At least tell Leon that her sister is being held captive, i'm pretty sure Leon would've likely helped Helena to rescue her sister and gone to the underground anyway. I think Leon is smart enough to not dismiss anything what Helena tells him after been through so much already. Besides, if we take Infinite Darkness into account which took place chronologically 6-7 years before RE6, conspiracy stuff or corrupted government officials using viruses for their own personal gain or motivation isn't a new thing in this series.
Sin 113: No argument there. Its a new virus
Sin 114: Yes, collecting files in this game is quite dumb. Especially when the most crucial key moments are hidden behind RE.NET website and are not accessible in the game itself. From what i gathered, Lepotitsa/Lepotica's were sent into the campus by Simmons and after spreading gas everywhere they self-destruct themselves, but we never see them doing this in the game itself. It also doesn't help that some of character moments in this game fell flat for me, because the files you found on website reveal more insight on the characters and their motivations, but are hardly discussed in the game itself. Like Deborah's final letter to her sister for example. Can you imagine how impactful it would've been had Helena found her sister's letter, telling how much she loves her after dealing with her in a boss fight?
Sin 115: I know someone quite well that has VHS player even to this day.
Sin 116: I do question Dartigan's taste in porn though
Sin 117: Referring to Sin 116. Only thing we see is her boobs
Sin 118: Possible, though not explained
Sin 119: Its possible. Though why don't Leon and Helena take video tape with them? That has clear evidence on Simmons by just looking at his hand with ring on it with Family Insignia? I guess it could be argued that Leon was too shooked by the revelation
Sin 120: No comment
Sin 130: Yes, shooting Helena would be extremely extreme for Leon to do. But why is it so difficult to tell someone their family member is in danger? I get that Helena was probably racing a clock and wanted to get to Deborah as soon as possible which is understandable, but also quite frustrating.
Sin 131: To be fair, this was before the place started collapsing
Sin 132: Brzak and traps? I get it, but place suddenly collapsing is quite convenient. Although, chalk it up to place slowly collapsing due it being around for centuries.
Sin 133: This boss fight looks pretty...suggestive
Sin 134: No argument there. Then again, we have Tyrants that walk around naked and they don't have...you know
Sin 135: That shot has been used in various movies
Sin 137: Referring to Sin 130
Sin 138: There is also Del Lago in RE4 and Irving's boss battle in RE5
Sin 139: Initially i thought Mines of Moria joke was funny, but this ain't a sin. If he was referring that RE6 is plagiarizing the Lord of the Rings, then by his logic every video game is plagiarizing others.
Sin 140: Another pointless sin from Dartigan
Sin 141: It was quite convenience that it had harpoon attached to it somehow, unless i missed something in the game.
Sin 142: No comment
Sin 143: Not a shark, although they admitted they designed Brzak after Bull shark.
Sin 144: Scene itself is quite silly though. Then again, RE has had multiple ridiculous stuff in it
Sin 145: I admit, i initially missed that mutant fish was actually based on human, but it still looks shark to me. Even then, mutant fish from human or not, fish don't have vocal chords, unless it has specific biology that allows it.
Sin 146: No comment
Sin 147: This detail of the nuclear bomb has been quite contradictory to the series. RE archives claim its nuclear while Biohazard archives and Kawamura claim its thermobaric, though with the case of RE archives could be translation error. As for sterilization of the city, i'm not expert on politics, but i recall that direct confirmation has to come from The President before you launch a nuke. Although, Simmons had influence in this
Sin 148: This one creates intelligence mutants, zombies and even clones. Though it could be argued CV was the first game to introduce the cloning of Ashfords but it was more subtle.
Sin 149: No argument there
Sin 150: Yes, she faked their deaths, but considering how she declared them dead just few hours ago i don't think people are that quick to forget faces. Especially when Face recognition has been a thing since 2010 and this game takes place in 2013. Of course, if that happened then the game would likely ended there.
Sin 151. To be fair, that detail is only found on RE.NET and not in the game itself. Which to be honest, is one of the bad ways you can tell your story. Still better than RE8, though
Sin 152: I guess it comes with the personal preference on QTEs. They certainly made this scene easier in PS4 port.
Sin 153: I guess he mistook the way scene was handled as Leon seeing Ada or something, i dunno.
Sin 154: I like to believe their injuries would be worse than what is shown.
Sin 165: I don't think he was sinning the reunion on itself, but yeah his reasoning is dumb. Unless, you count Outbreak cast some of them went on with their lives
Sin 166: It would be funny to see Leon's hair messed up once.
Sin 167: I can conclude that line he thinks is dumb i guess
Sin 169: I'm guessing he was very nonchalant about the whole and didn't care about finding out.
Sin 168: Ok, that was pretty funny.
Sin 169: But he also doesn't stop Chris from trying to kill her nor tells him that they need valuable info out of her.
Sin 269: The fight itself is cool, although i don't think its that dark to see.
Sin 270: Granted, i think with characters being thrown into the dangerous situations are properly equipped, except for Carla who is running in a skirt, then again Ada wore dress in RE4
Sin 271: Problem is once again that Capcom stored that detail of Sherry and Simmons's relationship into the background files in Extra features. We don't get to know and see their relationship unfold.
Sin 272: No comment
Sin 277: No comment
Sin 279: I have no words
Sin 280: I do find it funny that they don't stop firing once Leon and Helena ducked in the cover, but keep shooting at the same location where Jake and Sherry were only to be stopped by Simmons.
Sin 281: I accidentally triggered it on accident
Sin 291: No argument on the J'avo sneaking up on Simmons, but they were clearly stairs next to the platform so its not like they couldn't have followed them.
Sin 292: Convenient time for speeding train
Sin 293: Crushing something in anger has been quite cliche especially in anime
Sin 294: To me it looks like action setpiece of Michael Bay movie instead of something like Speed or Mission Impossible
Sin 295: Sadly, most of Simmons's motives are only explained in background files and vaguely hinted at in the game.
Sin 296: Transformers-Simmons
Sin 297: No argument on unrealism in the series. But what are exactly the limitations to the C-Virus?
Sin 298: It is quite over-the-top, though.
Sin 299: No comment
Sin 300: Can't believe Dartigan missed that part where you have to shoot Simmons to make him trip and he couldn't build enough speed and velocity to derail the train where Leon and Helena were on.
Sin 310: It is cool scene, realism be damned
Sin 311: I can only conclude that he thought Helena shooting Simmons in the head made more damage than getting hit by train earlier
Sin 312: I am aware of the effects of enhanced C-Virus, but it gets ridiculous to the point when the game pretends that it's gonna be the end of Simmons only to appear alive moments later.
Sin 313: No argument there
Sin 314: No comment
Sin 315: It comes to personal preference over all and i love Dawn of the Dead Remake. Also in Leon's report in RE6, he says that these zombies are more faster and more agile than zombies in RE2.
Sin 316: Good point
Sin 316: Admittedly, character models are done fantastically here minus some of the NPCs. As for Leon and Ada, of course he would be shocked even if this isn't the first time he thought she died.
Sin 317: Sure, but it is quite convenient that Leon runs into trucks
Sin 318: Plot armor defies all logic
Sin 328: Um...no. Because if you go to Cutscenes section where they have placed the timeline for each cutscenes. Then yes, the scenes where Helena gets injured and has to be patched by Leon happens between scenes where they get knocked back by explosion and facing against Simmons again later on.
Sin 329: I am getting Independence Day flashbacks from this scene
Sin 330: Question is how did he get infected? We learn through Marhawa Desire that zombies that C-Virus creates do not infect through bites, but by gas. And if this guy was on the helicopter the entire time, how did he get infected, but not his partner?
Sin 335: Michael Bay comment is bit overkill, but i can "sort" of see his point due to how over the top action is in this game
Sin 336: No comment
Sin 337: I do question how Simmons is able to not transform to T-Rex, but also revert back to his Hellhound form and also turn back to human? What are the rules on C-Virus anymore?
Sin 338: But we didn't see any J'avo in Leon's campaign aside from the one who shot Simmons and this takes way long after the first mission with Chris.
Sin 339: You can clearly see blood splatter from Leon's back when Simmons shoots him with bones
Sin 340: I understand the effects, but its still silly how they keep faking him possibly dying only reveal he is alive minutes later.
Sin 341: I'm guessing they keep numbers with each other
Sin 346: While its explained in Ada's campaign, but lightning storm was really convenient in order them to severely damage Simmons
Sin 347: I do find it funny after been disintegrated, he still has enough to revert back to human
Sin 348: Writers and their tricks. But in all seriousness, if we are gonna use "Because writer says so" as defense, then does that mean we should stop critiquing movies like Sharknado because it was intentionally made bad?
Sin 349: While she says they can defeat the virus, but don't clarify how after all the break loose in Tachi.
Sin 350: I'm not expert on US laws, but having hand in President's murder is gonna be quite severe whether she pulled the trigger or not. I can't exactly confirm it, but at worse she should be on suspension for few months instead in prison for life as Dartigan claims
Sin 351: I'm guessing he is referring to game not specifying in which part of Eastern Europe
Sin 356: This is gonna sound complicated if not controversial. First and foremost, i wanna say that i love the idea on Chris reaching his breaking point and possibly suffer PTSD from all the men he lost and after what he's been through which is understandable. I wanted to appreciate it, but some issues lies in execution. For 1: His PTSD fueled amnesia only lasts in single chapter and afterwards he keeps running off recklessly trying to take down Carla and being jerk to everyone. 2: The game kinda glosses over on what he's been doing in 6 months which is only touched upon in the files. 3. While its understandable why Chris is so pissed and not in his right mind, but in some scenes he comes off as incredibly petty and kinda childish as i get into later. 4. It kinda undermines his growth in RE5 in which the game starts with Chris with more cynical outlook on life due to how losing Jill took toll on him(and learning info about her was his only hope) and questions if his fighting and hardwork all are worth it anymore. But, at the end of the game, after Wesker's defeat and getting Jill back, Chris has now regained his hope for the world and has gained new sense of purpose of fighting for the better future. Yes, the flashback chapter on Edonia does this seem head to the direction where RE5 ended with Chris becoming captain of the squad and leading a new squad which was great touch. But that is quickly over during the end of the chapter and Chris becomes amnesiac whose haunted by guilt he can't remember(according to the files) so he runs away and spends his time drinking at the bar for whole 6 months. RE5 started out with Chris is dark place, but regained new sense of hope at the end of the game only to lose it again at the time of RE6 with difference being adding Post-Traumatic Amnesia to the mix. Not saying that this couldn't happen to Chris, because it can, but i kinda felt disappointed that it makes Chris's arc and struggles in RE5 feel bit redundant. This is the case when it would have been better for Jill to come back to pull Chris out of brink like how Chris freed Jill from being mind-controlled for over 3 years in the last game, but she is not even mentioned in the game or in game files or RE.NET files. It is explained in Revelations 2 where Jill was doing, but that was like 3 years too late as Revelations 2 game came after RE6's release.
Sin: 357: How many steroid jokes has Dartigan made in his videos?
Sin: 358-363: No argument there
Sin: 364: No argument there
Sin: 365: It does bring in question how much Chris does remember. Does he still remember Claire or Jill after regaining his memory? And come to think of it, where was Jill and Claire when Chris went missing for 6 months. I know that it was mentioned in Revelations 2 but that game came 3 years too late since RE6 was released
Sin: 366: He does blame himself for failing to save Richard in RE1 Remake, although it turns out to be Wesker's fault when Chris finds out. While Chris wasn't the leader of S.T.A.R.S, he obviously cared about them and the reason why he went to investigate Umbrella and find ways to bring them down was because of the honor of his fallen S.T.A.R.S members. While yes, leading the team on your own adds much bigger responsibility, but sadly, most of Chris's men feel like cannon fodder thrown into the meat grinder than proper characters.
Sin 367: I can see Piers means well, but pulling the amnesiac PTSD-ridden soldier back on the field without psychic evaluation is one of the worst decisions you could make. Yes, Chris has the reputation of thwarting many outbreaks and bioterrorist attacks, but he is clearly not in his right mind to make rational calls or could lose himself to anger as he does once he regains memory about his teammates and Carla, whom he mistakens as Ada.
Sin 368: As i said in earlier post
Sin 369: No argument there
Sin 370: No comment
Sin 371: No argument there. I'm guessing Dartigan skipped all the files in previous RE games as well
Sin 372: Wished the game would explore some of the ramifications on C-Virus and what are its limits, because it can basically do anything
Sin 373: Don't think body armor protects you enough from RPG warhead that would penetrate human body and even if it didn't penetrate the armor, the explosion itself would be big enough to 100% kill human
Sin 378: No comment
Sin 379: Because in good action movies explosions and falling debris happen for reason and not randomly?
Sin 380: It still doesn't explain why are they bombing the building clear of all the J'avo. Unless, they were worried it could still have more inside somewhere.
Sin 385: If John McClane survived boat explosion with mere inches away from him, don't see why Chris wouldn't survive this. Although, realistically, they would suffer from severe 2nd and 3rd degree burns at best.
Sin 386: No argument there. Although, triggering flashback has been thing in movies alot and people call it cliche
Sin 387: No comment
Sin 388: Although in Leon's case, most vehicles get crashed or blown up quite often during his campaign. Some due to his driving skills and some out of his control.
Sin 389: I think most of us wanted to climb on that thing to get cool and stylish kill than just shoot it
Sin 390: Finn seems like a typical fanboy archetype i have seen in all sorts of media before. At least he didn't turn evil
Sin 391-400: Guess he forgot that scene when he was making the script, but yeah, that scene was still quite ridiculous.
Sin 401-406: Maybe, but writers aren't immune to criticism.
Sin 407: I'm sorry, but you are forgetting that Ada was mentioned in RE1 as part of puzzle in John's diary.
Sin 408: No comment
Sin 409-418: No argument there. Although so far we have had organizations like Umbrella, its rival company called "Third Organization but don't think they intentionally wanted to spread around the virus. Aside from what you just listed, we also have the terrorist group in Degeneration, although the film quite implies it was all Tricell's doing and Arias's attempt to infect population in Vendetta(although that took place after RE6)
Sin 419: I do wonder how it works though.
Sin 420: No argument there
Sin 430: No complaints about RCS's performance. He did fantastic job and he will always be the definitive Chris Redfield for me. Buuuut...it pains me to say this, but Finn didn't grow enough for me to care about him. He does have good qualities in him, he is kindhearted rookie who wants to do good and is excited to work with Chris whose he is fanboying over. But other than that, there is not much to him. Sure, in the files we learn that he had mother back at States, but his character failed to captivate me.
Sin 431: From what it looked like, it look like dead end corridor and i don't want to use theories as irrefutable fact even if its good theory.
Sin 432: Granted, Nicholai was not much of a boss fight as you take him down with single rocket. In RE6 it's a boss fight and it takes ridiculous amount of damage.
Sin 433: No argument there, although i do like Yawn fight
Sin 434: Well given the state that Chris was in, Piers should have known better than that that Chris likely wasn't fit to lead the unit.
Sin 435: No argument there.
Sin 436: Not sure on why she would want to torment Chris so badly when her main goal is to make Simmons suffer. Unless, Carla is really sadist which is likely true.
Sin 437: I agree, although i think Dartigan should be blaming Piers for deaths of the first team by his logic. Chris is the one that specifically ordered Piers to not let Carla out of sight and he does. My point is that they were probably too busy in fighting that they didn't notice her disappear.
Sin 438: Since one of the signs of being infected with C-Virus make your body combust. I'm surprised C4 didn't ignite and blow up.
Sin 439: Mythbusters got you covered
Sin 444: No comment
Sin 449: No comment
Sin 454: No comment on the laugh. Granted, Chris is being quite petty here. Yes, i am aware of him wanting revenge, but he really makes himself look like fool here. Maybe it was done intentionally, but still
Sin 453: No argument there. Also what irritates me is that you can stuck on invisible wall at the moment
Sin 553: I like this scene overall, however my issue with this scene how Chris's change here felt little too sudden for me. Chapter 3 reinforces that Chris and Piers have conflicting goals and they spend majority of Chapter 3 arguing about the mission and what's right. You would think there would've been some payoff to their conflict later on in the story, but after one pep talk from Leon, Chris is almost immediately becomes nice with Piers. I do like that Chris is finally taking some responsibility from his actions, but i felt the the game took the easy way out for their conflict.
Sin 554: No comment. Although, arrogance has been used in almost every bad guy in these games
Sin 555: No comment
Sin 556: No argument there
Sin 561: Meh
Sin 562: Because of course
Sin 563: It does activate, but still with countdown.
Sin 568: No comment
Sin 570: Meh
Sin 571: Irony perhaps. Deep? Arguable
Sin 572: The amount of times this game tries to play every silly stuff seriously, it comes off as often as unintentionally hilarious.
Sin 573: Dartigan's hate boner for Chris is very apparent.
Sin 574: Jake grew up in Europe, its likely he learned American Accent during his time as mercenary.
Sin 575: Also Chris tells Piers that despite Wesker deserving what he got that he was still Jake's father and he needed to know. I was also wrong about this, even though the scene is bit too overdramatic for my taste when i get to later. But i can understand why Chris spilled his beans.
Sin 574: I'm actually one of the people who still passionately love RE5
Sin 575: No argument there
Sin 576: I'd like to ask someone who works in a place like this
SIn 577: I think Piers getting his right arm impaled and crushed was simple coincidence as HAOS grabbed what was nearest to it and Piers's right arm was the closest to it.
Sin 578: No argument there
Sin 579: To be fair, the file about HAOS is only excluded in RE.NET and not in game itself. It was also said that once Carla's vital signs cease to function, her group will initiate Plan D to unleash HAOS whether its incomplete or not. Which explains that had Leon not interfered Chris at that moment, Haos would have been released as soon as Chris shot her death and no one would be able to stop it in time.
Sin 580: No argument there
Sin 581: No comment
Sin 582: I agree that it should have had cameo on Jill. Also why go to the exact place where he started in? I get that its supposed to be symbolic Book end scene, but still.
Sin 583: That's neat detail, but how would Jake know that lullaby
Sin 584: Apple joke is overused
Sin 585: No argument there
Sin 586: If someone with many eyes stared at me i would be like "The heck, man?"
Sin 591: No comment
Sin 592: We don't know
Sin 593: I understand with Jake though
Sin 594: I don't think Chrysalid virus was ever said in the game, but only in the files.
Sin 595: No argument there
Sin 596: Granted, on the launch you wouldn't know this detail until you completed all 3 campaigns. But yeah, i agree overall. Though the files don't really explain how Carla got hold on Wesker's DNA. Sure, it could be single strand of Wesker's hair she obtained.
Sin 597: No argument there, although Jake stumbles quite a bit on his run.
Sin 598: No argument there. Although, even Spiderman would get damaged from explosion.
Sin 599: Ustanak had great potential, but i think he fails to be scary as Nemesis for the fact that you are constantly put into mandatory fights with him where you kick his ass(Minus, the hide n seek section which was pretty good) whereas with Nemesis it was more fight or flight situation, leaving only 3 mandatory fights with him. Nemesis also has tendency to randomly show up to ruin your day and you can feel his presence close with music changing and hearing his voice from distant and that was terrifying. However, i will say i love Ustanak's design and attaching claw or any other kind of weapon to his missing arm makes him formidable enemy.
Sin 600: On first glance i can see why some may not see it due to their different hairstyles, but on closer look they do kinda resemble each other.
Sin 605: "A**holes eat apples" joke again
Sin 606: No argument there, its great set up for his character, although i have some problems with some of the execution
Sin 607: I agree
Sin 608: Considering how far Ustanak can jump, its not too impossible.
Sin 609: It looked like explosion gave him boost
Sin 614: It does look quite ridiculous how one moment Ustanak has giant claw, but when he goes off camera for about 2 seconds, he has freaking minigun attached to his arm.
Sin 615: No comment
Sin 616: 🤷‍♂
Sin 617: No comment on his life...
Sin 618: Unfortunately, her healing factor does not add much beyond Chapter 2.
Sin 619: I think its the scenery that looks kinda romantic and judging what we see throughout the game there are clear signs of implying romance between Jake and Sherry. I do like Sherry's story about the past events and Leon and Claire.
Sin 620: No argument there
Sin 630: No comment
Sin 631: I do like the "Sins of the Fathers" aspect from Jake and Sherry, but i am still questioning Wesker's lineage because this comes up way after his death.
Sin 632: It is Resident Evil game, but i dislike vehicle sections in this game
Sin 633: No comment
Sin 638: Again...no comment
Sin 639: I think people who would work at mines would wear different outfit than just T-shirt
Sin 640: I agree, plus Ustanak is big guy. He wouldn't slip by through tight corridor.
Sin 641: No argument there, although its funny on dying state Sherry says she can't regenerate fast enough. So...yeah. Another point is how he didn't sin Jake being hit by Ustanak's power drill to the face. That would leave some serious injuries to the head and i get that Jake has similar powers as his father, but Wesker wasn't impervious to knives either as Sheva stabbed him in the wrist with knife in RE5.
Sin 642: My only question with this scene is how can Carla walk around in a skirt with her bare legs exposed in a cold weather? At least Sherry seemed wearing right gear for winter.
Sin 643: Granted, it is not explicitly said on how many times he has tried this. And also he only disarmed one armed guy when he had two armed guys still aiming their guns at him. They could have shot Jake right there in there, unless they need him alive. Also, how come Jake's hair hasn't grown in 6 months?
Sin 644: Not really, because they send a FREAKING TANK against them.
Sin 645: No comment
Sin 650: I think there are more pressing issues on Dartigan's video than just spelling errors. Because if i were to count every misspelled line from him, i would be here all day.
Sin 651: No comment
Sin 652: No comment again
Sin 702: Its highly convenient how those clothes in those lockers fit with them perfectly.
Sin 703: No argument there
Sin 704: Even in fictional universe, there needs to be established rules.
Sin 705: No argument there
Sin 706: No comment
Sin 711: I have no words
Sin 712: While tank maneuvers slowly, how does Jake know the tank would miss the shot?
Sin 717: Not a big fan on motorcycle sequence in this game
Sin 723: First of all, maneuvering motorcycle in this game is really stiff and hard to maneuver and one of the reasons i think vehicle sections suck in this game
Sin 724: No comment
Sin 733: Oh boy
Sin 734: To be honest, i thought this was one of the not-so-good moments in Jake's campaign mainly due to how stiff the controls were
Sin 735: No argument there
Sin 736: Fighting unkillable enemies can become tiresome when overused and frustrated when having to constantly fight the thing which it did for me.
Sin 737: No comment
Sin 738: No comment
Sin 739: No argument there.
Sin 740: Not defending Dartigan here, but even i have sometimes trouble with spelling names of some of these monsters in the game like Lepotitsa(which is why i call them Lepotica), Brzak or Rasklapanje
Sin 741: No argument there
Sin 742: I guess
Sin 743: No comment
Sin 744: Ok, first of all, Jake doesn't fully allude to this in the game. He talks about his father 2 times in the whole game minus the encounter. 1. Where he blames him for inheriting his blood and abandoning. 2. When he asks Sherry if Chris knew Wesker was his father which could also seen as Jake being simply curious. And most of their journey has been Jake and Sherry about making the cure out of Jake's blood than search for Wesker. We don't get much what Jake is truly feeling about his father and it often comes off to people that Jake's anger at Chris being too sudden. Jake's feelings are mostly touched in the files and now i can say why i dislike how files are collected in this game. They leave out crucial character moments, one of them being Jake inner thoughts about Wesker which should have been included in the game itself. Another in-game file is about Jake's mother's final letter to her son in which seems to imply that Jake not only wanted to confront his father, but also wanted to honor his mom's last wishes which makes Jake's anger at Chris perfectly justifiable. But, this is not alluded in the game at all. Jake never mentions anything about that. So yeah...he has good development, but it is fumbled by sloppy execution and it pains me to say it.
Sin 745: No argument there.
Sin 746: No comment
Sin 751: RE5 is pretty awesome
Sin 752: No argument there
Sin 753: No argument there
Sin 754: Best boss in the game
Sin 755: Its silly, but cool
Sin 756: Even the files say who funded Neo-Umbrella is unknown
Sin 757: Its explained, but its highly convenient
Sin 762: No comment
Sin 763: Once again, no comment.
Sin 764: Dunno
Sin 769: Well, its true actually
Sin 770: No comment
Sin 771: I do question on how that works exactly
Sin 772: No argument there
Sin 782: No argument here either
Sin 783: Meh
Sin 784: Carla is one crazy woman
Sin 785: But Agent is barely a character and can't do anything until Ada proceeds. And while we get more behind the scenes of the events that we didn't see before, there are parts where i felt the game drags during her campaign.
Sin 786: If this virus can create zombies, mutants, insects and clones, then what are the limitations to it?
Sin 787: How do you know if its impossible to happen someday in the future? Not saying it will, but still.
Sin 788: No argument there
Sin 789: He was in Raccoon City, yes, but left before the outbreak happened in the city.
Sin 790: No comment
Sin 800: Silly dialogue has been franchise's sin from the very first game. It doesn't get pass here either.
Sin 801: I have no words.
Sin 802: I heard original intention for Damnation was to have love story between Leon and Ada, but Capcom refused that. And sadly this is the last time we see Leon and Ada together in upcoming games and movies.
Sin 803: I can only think Ada had a hunch that Leon might need it.
Sin 804: I think the real sin with this game is teasing for character in future games that does not appear in over next 10 years.

Phew, finally i'm done with this. It took me long to make this response and i needed to take breaks to calm down.
First and foremost, i wanna tell you that you put so much effort in this video and you certainly explained everything
well in lot of detail in this video so great job on that. This response was meant to be merely my counterpoint to your video on which points i agree and which i disagree with. I do think Dartigan has poor research on video games, but i find it hard to take him seriously or believe everything what he says. I will say i understand the frustration on people overhating RE6. It is quite overhated game and it does deserve credit where its due, but still it's not untouchable masterpiece that can never be critiqued or analyzed as some say. I think people are entitled to love or dislike RE6 as long as both parties are respectful to each other's point of view.
Interesting. Are you planning to create more counterpoints to omega's other resident evil videos? I agree with your point in regards to re net portions not making it to the game's files but a lot of dramatic aspects you mention are what develops the story along with the characters.

Something ı also want to mention which ı discussed before but the intended point with c-virus is to mainly showcase g and t-veronica's potentials. This in a way characterizes progenitor which is the heart and soul of the series. There isnt really any inconsistency. The way gas works is for t-veronica part to kill the victim before g part revives them as a zombie. I doubt t-veronica could cause infection since nosferatu's gas cant cause one at all and the 2 viruses by themselves are weaker than previous versions of g and t-veronica, hence the reasoning for combining them to create a more vicious strain. Enhanced version showcases this even more which was what carla wanted for simmons. Him going back and forth between his mutations showcases t-veronica's potential at them similar to steve turning back to his human form once before dying.

But anyway ı watched the video multiple times already and ı'll continue to do this. It's everything ı was expecting for and even better!
 
Interesting. Are you planning to create more counterpoints to omega's other resident evil videos? I agree with your point in regards to re net portions not making it to the game's files but a lot of dramatic aspects you mention are what develops the story along with the characters.

Something ı also want to mention which ı discussed before but the intended point with c-virus is to mainly showcase g and t-veronica's potentials. This in a way characterizes progenitor which is the heart and soul of the series. There isnt really any inconsistency. The way gas works is for t-veronica part to kill the victim before g part revives them as a zombie. I doubt t-veronica could cause infection since nosferatu's gas cant cause one at all and the 2 viruses by themselves are weaker than previous versions of g and t-veronica, hence the reasoning for combining them to create a more vicious strain. Enhanced version showcases this even more which was what carla wanted for simmons. Him going back and forth between his mutations showcases t-veronica's potential at them similar to steve turning back to his human form once before dying.

But anyway ı watched the video multiple times already and ı'll continue to do this. It's everything ı was expecting for and even better!
When did i say it was inconsistent? All i was questioning what are the limits to the C-virus. Yes, i am aware that C-virus is hybrid T-Veronica and G-virus. I can understand insect like mutations due T-Veronica strain, but how do some turn into lizards and some into flying beasts? Is it because different DNA and cell structure. And in case of enhanced C-virus, how does it mutate uncontrollably with Carla and Piers, but Simmons can switch forms at will? It leaves some questions. Also if you are using Steve as an example for reverting to human before dying, then how do you account for Nosferatu when we kill him as Claire? As for gas thing, i gathered it was poison gas.

Lastly, what were you trying to prove with this? Its not like i was telling you that you were wrong to like RE6.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom